Blog

– The Body Keeps the Score & Waking the Tiger

In the realm of psychological literature, numerous publications have explored the intricate relationship between trauma and its effects on the human mind and body. Two notable examples that delve into this subject matter are The Body Keeps the Score by Bessel van der Kolk and Waking the Tiger by Peter A. Levine. These influential books offer distinct perspectives on trauma, its impact on individuals, and the potential for healing.

While both texts share a common focus on trauma, they approach the subject from different angles, providing readers with diverse insights into the phenomenon. The Body Keeps the Score emphasizes the ways trauma affects the entire organism, including the brain, body, and nervous system, while Waking the Tiger takes a somatic experiencing approach, emphasizing the body’s innate wisdom in recovering from traumatic experiences.

This comparative study aims to examine the key themes, methodologies, and contributions of these two books, shedding light on their unique approaches to understanding and treating trauma. By exploring the overlapping and diverging perspectives of van der Kolk and Levine, we can gain a deeper understanding of the complexities of trauma and how it impacts individuals differently.

Throughout this comparative analysis, we will explore the main concepts present in each book, such as the role of memory and the body, the importance of re-establishing safety, and the significance of releasing trapped energy associated with traumatic experiences. Through this examination, we hope to uncover the distinct contributions these texts offer to the field of trauma psychology and highlight the potential for interdisciplinary approaches to healing.

As we embark on this comparative journey, it is important to recognize that trauma is a deeply personal experience, and the healing process varies for each individual. Nevertheless, by examining the comprehensive frameworks presented in The Body Keeps the Score and Waking the Tiger, we can expand our knowledge and contemplate the best practices for addressing trauma’s profound effects on the human psyche and physical well-being.

Summary of Two Books

The Body Keeps the Score

“The Body Keeps the Score” is a groundbreaking book written by Bessel van der Kolk, a renowned psychiatrist and trauma expert. The book delves into the profound effects of trauma on the human mind and body, highlighting the understanding that traumatic experiences are not only stored in our memory but also imprinted in our bodies.

Van der Kolk draws from decades of research and clinical practice to explain how trauma disrupts the brain’s normal functioning, leading to a range of physical and psychological symptoms. He explores various forms of trauma, including childhood abuse, combat-related PTSD, and sexual assault, and discusses the long-lasting impact they can have on individuals.

Throughout the book, van der Kolk emphasizes the significance of treating trauma holistically. He presents a wide array of therapeutic techniques, such as EMDR (Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing), neurofeedback, yoga, and theater, which have shown promising results in helping patients heal from trauma. The author also advocates for the integration of mind-body approaches alongside traditional talk therapy methods.

“The Body Keeps the Score” offers hope and validation to those who have experienced trauma while providing valuable insights for mental health practitioners and caregivers. By shedding light on the complex relationship between trauma, the brain, and the body, van der Kolk encourages a more comprehensive and compassionate approach towards healing from trauma.

Waking the Tiger

“Waking the Tiger: Healing Trauma” by Peter A. Levine is a book that explores the nature of trauma and offers insights into how trauma can be healed. The central concept of the book revolves around understanding trauma from an evolutionary perspective and utilizing this understanding to overcome its detrimental effects.

Levine argues that trauma is not solely a psychological issue but also deeply rooted in our physiology. He introduces the concept of the “trauma vortex,” where traumatic experiences create patterns of physiological responses that become stuck in the body, causing symptoms like anxiety, depression, and chronic pain.

The author draws on his extensive experience as a therapist specializing in trauma to present strategies for healing. Levine emphasizes the importance of reconnecting with bodily sensations and instinctual processes as a means of resolving trauma. By learning to access and release the trapped energy associated with traumatic experiences, individuals can begin to heal and move towards post-traumatic growth.

Throughout the book, Levine shares numerous case studies and personal anecdotes to illustrate his ideas. He explores various therapeutic techniques, including Somatic Experiencing, which focuses on renegotiating the fight, flight, or freeze response associated with trauma.

“Waking the Tiger” offers a holistic approach to understanding and addressing trauma, emphasizing the mind-body connection and the potential for recovery. It empowers readers to recognize their own resilience and provides practical tools to help them navigate the complex journey of healing from trauma.

Comparison Between Two Books

Similarities in Healing Trauma

The Body Keeps the Score by Bessel van der Kolk and Waking the Tiger by Peter A. Levine are both highly regarded books that delve into the topic of healing trauma. While they approach the subject from different perspectives, there are several notable similarities between the two works:

1. Understanding trauma’s impact:

Both books emphasize the profound impact of trauma on an individual’s mind, body, and emotions. They explore how traumatic experiences can shape a person’s worldview, relationships, and overall well-being.

• Body-centered approach:

Both authors emphasize the importance of incorporating the body in trauma healing. They argue that trauma is not only stored in memories and thoughts but also imprinted in physical sensations and reactions. By working with the body, individuals can process and release trauma more effectively.

• Importance of somatic experiencing:

The authors highlight the significance of somatic experiencing, which involves paying attention to bodily sensations, movements, and gestures associated with trauma. They explain how this approach allows individuals to gradually regulate their nervous system responses and discharge trapped energy resulting from traumatic experiences.

• Role of mindfulness:

Both books stress the value of mindfulness practices in healing trauma. Mindfulness techniques help individuals cultivate present-moment awareness, foster self-compassion, and develop a sense of safety within their bodies. By anchoring themselves in the present, individuals can learn to manage overwhelming emotions and regain control over their lives.

• Empowerment and self-regulation:

Van der Kolk and Levine agree that trauma healing involves empowering individuals to take an active role in their recovery. They provide tools and strategies for self-regulation, helping readers build resilience, establish healthy boundaries, and develop coping mechanisms to navigate triggers and trauma-related symptoms.

• Integration of traditional therapies:

Both books recognize the benefits of integrating traditional therapeutic approaches, such as cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT), Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR), and psychodynamic therapy, with body-centered techniques. This integrative approach aims to provide a comprehensive framework for healing trauma by addressing various aspects of an individual’s experience.

• Importance of storytelling and connection:

Van der Kolk and Levine emphasize the significance of storytelling, sharing experiences, and establishing connections as part of the healing process. They acknowledge that trauma can isolate individuals and that finding supportive communities or engaging in group therapy can help foster resilience and recovery.

In summary, both The Body Keeps the Score and Waking the Tiger explore the multifaceted nature of trauma and advocate for an integrated approach to healing that incorporates the body, mindfulness, empowerment, self-regulation, and connection with others.

Divergence in Healing Trauma

The Body Keeps the Score by Bessel van der Kolk and Waking the Tiger by Peter A. Levine are both influential books that explore the topic of trauma and its impact on individuals. Both authors draw upon their extensive experience in working with traumatized individuals to provide insights and guidance on healing from trauma. While there are some similarities between the two books, there are also notable divergences in terms of their approach to healing trauma.

1. Emphasis on the body:

One major divergence lies in the emphasis placed on the body in each book. The Body Keeps the Score focuses extensively on understanding the physiological and neurological effects of trauma on the body. Bessel van der Kolk explores various somatic approaches, such as yoga, neurofeedback, and EMDR, which aim to regulate the body’s response to trauma. On the other hand, Waking the Tiger places a stronger emphasis on the role of somatic experiencing and the body’s innate ability to heal itself when given the opportunity to discharge traumatic energy.

• Approach to memory processing:

Another divergence can be seen in the authors’ approach to memory processing. In The Body Keeps the Score, van der Kolk discusses the importance of integrating traumatic memories through therapies like Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) and Narrative Exposure Therapy (NET). He highlights the significance of articulating and making sense of traumatic experiences within a safe therapeutic context. In contrast, Levine’s Waking the Tiger focuses on renegotiating traumatic memories and allowing them to complete their natural cycle of activation and resolution without getting stuck in chronic arousal or immobilization.

• Cultural and historical context:

The two books also differ in terms of their exploration of cultural and historical contexts surrounding trauma. The Body Keeps the Score delves into the impact of societal factors, such as poverty, war, and social inequality, on trauma prevalence and treatment. Van der Kolk emphasizes the importance of considering individual experiences within their broader cultural and historical context. In contrast, while Levine acknowledges the role of cultural influences, his primary focus is on the physiological and psychological aspects of trauma healing.

• Psychoeducation vs. experiential focus:

The books also diverge in their emphasis on psychoeducation versus experiential exploration. The Body Keeps the Score dedicates a significant portion to explaining the science behind trauma and its effects on the brain and body. Van der Kolk provides readers with a comprehensive understanding of trauma while incorporating case studies from his professional practice. Conversely, Waking the Tiger takes a more experiential approach, encouraging readers to connect with their own bodily sensations and instinctual responses to trauma through exercises and self-reflection.

These divergences highlight the unique perspectives and approaches that Bessel van der Kolk and Peter A. Levine bring to the subject of trauma healing. While both books offer valuable insights, readers may resonate more with one approach over the other based on their personal preferences and needs.

Conclusion

“The Body Keeps the Score” and “Waking the Tiger” are both valuable books that explore the effects of trauma on the body and mind. Here’s a brief comparison to help you determine which book may align more with your interests or needs:

“The Body Keeps the Score” by Bessel van der Kolk:

• Written by renowned psychiatrist Bessel van der Kolk, this book provides a comprehensive understanding of how trauma affects individuals.
• It combines scientific research, personal anecdotes, and clinical experiences to explain the impact of trauma on the brain, body, emotions, and relationships.
• “The Body Keeps the Score” offers insights into various therapeutic approaches that can help individuals recover from trauma and heal.
• This book is highly recommended for those seeking an in-depth exploration of trauma’s effects and potential avenues for recovery.

“Waking the Tiger” by Peter A. Levine:

• Authored by Peter A. Levine, a leading expert in the field of trauma healing, this book focuses on the physiological aspects of trauma.
• “Waking the Tiger” delves into the connection between trauma and the nervous system, highlighting the body’s innate ability to heal itself through natural mechanisms.
• By exploring the concept of “trauma release,” it offers practical exercises and techniques to release stored trauma and restore vitality.
• This book is particularly beneficial for those interested in somatic approaches to trauma healing and self-regulation.

Ultimately, the choice between the two books depends on your specific preferences and goals. If you are seeking a comprehensive overview of trauma and its effects, “The Body Keeps the Score” is an excellent choice. On the other hand, if you are specifically interested in the physiological aspects of trauma and somatic healing, “Waking the Tiger” may be more suitable. Both books provide valuable insights into trauma and can greatly contribute to personal growth and healing.