Blog

General James Longstreet and Rose West may seem like an unlikely pair to be the subjects of a comparative study. Longstreet, a Confederate general in the American Civil War, and West, a British serial killer, lived in different times and places, and operated in drastically different spheres of influence. However, upon closer examination, it becomes clear that both figures were highly controversial and polarizing, leaving behind complex legacies that continue to be debated to this day. In this study, we will explore the lives and actions of these two individuals as portrayed in the biographies written by Jeffry D. Wert and Jane Carter Woodrow, respectively, in order to gain a deeper understanding of the nuances of their characters and the lasting impacts of their actions.

Published in 1993, “General James Longstreet: The Confederacy’s Most Controversial Soldier” by Jeffry D Wert offers a comprehensive biography of one of the most prominent figures in the American Civil War. James Longstreet was a skilled and controversial Confederate general who played a significant role in key battles such as Bull Run and Gettysburg.

Wert’s biography delves into Longstreet’s early life, his military career, and his tumultuous relationship with fellow Confederate generals and political leaders. Longstreet’s close friendship with General Robert E. Lee and his strategic prowess on the battlefield are highlighted, providing a nuanced understanding of his contributions to the Confederate cause.

However, Longstreet’s post-war reputation was marred by controversies and criticisms, including accusations of betraying the Confederacy and his political alliances with the Republican Party. Wert examines these controversies and offers a balanced portrayal of Longstreet as a complex and multifaceted figure in American history.

Overall, “General James Longstreet” sheds light on the life and legacy of a controversial Civil War figure, offering readers a comprehensive and engaging account of Longstreet’s military career and personal struggles during one of the most turbulent periods in American history.

“Rose West” by Jane Carter Woodrow is a biography that delves into the life and crimes of Rosemary West, one of Britain’s most notorious female serial killers. The book follows Rosemary’s troubled upbringing, her tumultuous relationship with her husband Fred West, and their horrific crimes which included the abduction, torture, and murder of numerous young women. The author explores Rosemary’s psyche, her motivations, and the events that led to her becoming a cold-blooded killer. Through interviews with those who knew her, Woodrow paints a chilling portrait of a twisted and manipulative woman who committed unspeakable acts of violence.

General James Longstreet and Rose West, despite living in vastly different time periods and contexts, share some similarities as historical figures in their respective books.

Firstly, both Longstreet and West were controversial figures in their own right. Longstreet was a prominent Confederate general during the American Civil War, known for his disagreements with other Confederate leaders and controversial decisions on the battlefield. Similarly, Rose West was a notorious British criminal who was involved in a series of heinous crimes, shocking the public and leaving a lasting legacy of infamy.

Secondly, both Longstreet and West faced challenges and adversity throughout their lives. Longstreet struggled with his reputation and standing within the Confederate army, as well as his post-war political beliefs. West faced multiple hardships and traumas in her personal life, including abusive relationships and a tumultuous upbringing.

Finally, both Longstreet and West left a lasting impact on history, albeit in very different ways. Longstreet’s military career and legacy are still debated and analyzed by historians to this day, shaping our understanding of the Civil War and its key players. West’s crimes and notoriety have also left a lasting imprint on popular culture and criminal history, becoming a symbol of evil and depravity.

Overall, while General James Longstreet and Rose West come from very different backgrounds and contexts, they share some similarities as controversial and impactful historical figures in their respective books.

General James Longstreet and Rose West are two very different historical figures from different time periods and backgrounds.

General James Longstreet, as portrayed in Jeffry D Wert’s book, was a Confederate general during the American Civil War. He was a controversial figure who clashed with his fellow officers and superiors, but was ultimately one of the most successful and talented generals of the war. Wert’s book delves into Longstreet’s military strategy, his relationships with other generals, and his post-war political career. It provides a comprehensive look at his life and legacy, painting a complex picture of a man who was both admired and reviled.

On the other hand, Rose West, as depicted in Jane Carter Woodrow’s book, was a notorious British serial killer who, along with her husband Fred West, was responsible for the murders of at least 10 young women. Woodrow’s book explores the psychology and motivations behind Rose West’s crimes, as well as the impact they had on her family and the community. It delves into the chilling details of the murders and the investigation that eventually led to her and her husband’s arrest and conviction.

The key divergence between these two historical figures is the nature of their actions and the context in which they lived. General James Longstreet was a military leader who operated within the rules and norms of his time, while Rose West was a brutal criminal who violated those norms in the most horrific way possible. Longstreet’s legacy is mixed, with both praise and criticism for his actions during the Civil War, whereas Rose West is universally condemned for her heinous crimes.

Overall, while both books shed light on the lives and actions of historical figures, the divergence lies in their respective roles and legacies in history.

It ultimately depends on personal preference and interests. “General James Longstreet” is a biography of the Confederate general who played a significant role in the American Civil War. On the other hand, “Rose West” is a true crime book about a notorious British serial killer. If you are interested in military history and the Civil War, then “General James Longstreet” may be more worthy of reading. If you are interested in true crime and psychological analysis of criminals, then “Rose West” may be the better choice.