You are currently viewing Exploring Writing & Creativity: A Comparative Analysis of Bird by Bird and Novelist as a Profession

Exploring Writing & Creativity: A Comparative Analysis of Bird by Bird and Novelist as a Profession

——Bird by Bird by Ann Lamott & Novelist as a Profession by Haruki Murakami

In the realm of literature, writers hold a unique position as both creators and observers of the human experience. The process of writing itself, with its intricacies and challenges, has been a subject of interest and fascination for many authors. Two notable voices that delve into the world of writing are Ann Lamott in her book “Bird by Bird” and Haruki Murakami in his essay collection “Novelist as a Profession.” While both explore the craft of writing and offer guidance to aspiring writers, they do so from different perspectives and experiences. Lamott, an American writer renowned for her candidness, shares personal anecdotes and practical advice, while Murakami, an acclaimed Japanese novelist, reflects on his own writing journey and offers a philosophical approach to writing. This comparative study seeks to examine the similarities and differences between these two texts, exploring their unique insights and understanding of the writer’s life, in order to better comprehend the multifaceted nature of the writing process and its impact on the individuals who dare to embark on this artistic journey.

Brief Summary of Two Books

Bird by Bird by Ann Lamott

Bird by Bird” by Anne Lamott is a popular non-fiction book that offers guidance and insights into the writing process. The author, who is also an experienced writer and writing teacher, explores various aspects of writing, including finding inspiration, overcoming self-doubt, and dealing with writer’s block.

Lamott uses personal anecdotes and witty humor to share her perspectives on the challenges and joys of writing. She emphasizes the importance of taking one step at a time, or rather, “bird by bird,” in order to avoid being overwhelmed by the enormity of a writing project. The book also highlights the significance of forming a writing routine, nurturing one’s creativity, and engaging in diligent editing.

Furthermore, Lamott encourages writers to embrace imperfections and to write with honesty and vulnerability. She emphasizes the power of storytelling and the importance of connecting with readers on an emotional level.

“Bird by Bird” not only provides practical advice for aspiring writers but also delves into deeper themes such as the role of self-expression, the impact of criticism, and the value of perseverance in the face of obstacles. Overall, the book serves as a compassionate and insightful companion for any writer looking to cultivate their craft.

Novelist as a Profession by Haruki Murakami

Novelist as a Profession” is an essay collection by renowned Japanese author Haruki Murakami. In this book, Murakami shares his personal insights, experiences, and reflections on what it means to be a novelist and the craft of writing. Murakami dives into various aspects of his writing process, including his writing routine, influences, and the challenges he faced throughout his career. He also discusses the importance of solitude, music, and his love for jazz in his creative process, offering readers a glimpse into the unique methods he uses to cultivate inspiration. Additionally, Murakami delves into topics such as the relationship between the novelist and the reader, the role of popular culture in his works, and the significance of translating literature. Overall, “Novelist as a Profession” provides aspiring writers, fans of Murakami’s work, and literature enthusiasts with an intimate and thought-provoking perspective on the life of a successful novelist.

Comparison between Two Books

Bird by Bird/logo

Similarities in Writing & Creativity

Both “Bird by Bird” by Anne Lamott and “Novelist as a Profession” by Haruki Murakami explore the process of writing and offer insights into creativity. Despite being written by authors from different backgrounds, these books share several similarities in their approach to writing and creative expression.

1. Embracing Imperfection: Both Lamott and Murakami emphasize the importance of accepting imperfections in writing. They acknowledge that the first drafts are often messy and imperfect but encourage writers to keep going. According to Lamott, the key is to write “bird by bird,” focusing on small steps and allowing imperfections to exist. Murakami advises writers to embrace the ambiguity of their creative process since writing is an ongoing journey where perfection is elusive.

2. Discipline and Routine: Both authors emphasize the significance of discipline and establishing a writing routine. Lamott talks about the importance of showing up regularly to write, regardless of inspiration or motivation. Murakami, known for his rigorous writing routines, details his methodical approach of waking up early and dedicating himself to writing for hours each day. Both authors stress that creativity is nurtured by consistent effort rather than relying solely on bursts of inspiration.

3. Self-Reflection and Observation: Lamott and Murakami highlight the importance of self-reflection and observation in the writing process. Lamott advises writers to pay attention to their experiences and thoughts, allowing them to explore their internal landscapes and translate them into their writing. Murakami, in his memoir, shares his belief that writers should be keen observers of the world and tap into their own memories and emotions, using those observations as material for their work.

4. The Role of Perseverance: Both books emphasize the importance of perseverance and resilience in the face of challenges. Lamott emphasizes that writing involves facing rejection, self-doubt, and criticism but encourages writers to push through these obstacles. Similarly, Murakami shares his experiences of overcoming various setbacks and failures in his writing career, emphasizing the need to persist and not be discouraged by setbacks.

5. Honesty and Authenticity: Both authors stress the importance of writing truthfully and authentically. Lamott urges writers to be honest about their experiences, feelings, and observations, encouraging them to find their unique voice. Murakami also emphasizes the need for writers to be true to themselves and not try to imitate others, urging them to embrace their idiosyncrasies and write from their own perspectives.

In summary, “Bird by Bird” and “Novelist as a Profession” share similarities in their emphasis on embracing imperfection, establishing discipline, observing the world, persevering through challenges, and being honest in one’s writing. Both books provide valuable insights into the creative process, offering guidance and encouragement to aspiring writers.

Divergences in Writing & Creativity

Bird by Bird by Ann Lamott and Novelist as a Profession by Haruki Murakami are two celebrated works that provide valuable insights into the world of writing and creativity. While both books touch upon similar themes, they diverge in their perspectives on the writing process, the role of discipline, and the source of inspiration.

In Bird by Bird, Ann Lamott emphasizes the importance of embracing imperfection and vulnerability in the writing process. Lamott encourages aspiring writers to take small steps, writing “bird by bird,” and to not be discouraged by self-doubt or fear of criticism. She promotes a more organic and intuitive approach to writing, where the act itself leads to new ideas and discoveries. For Lamott, the creative process is highly personal and emotional, making writing a means of self-expression and healing.

On the other hand, Novelist as a Profession by Haruki Murakami adopts a more disciplined and methodical approach to writing. Murakami emphasizes the importance of routine, dedication, and perseverance. He suggests that inspiration can be elusive and unreliable, but by adhering to a set writing schedule and consistently putting in the effort, writers can create a conducive environment for creativity to flourish. Murakami sees writing as a profession that demands commitment and sacrifice, requiring one to consistently hone their skills and push through obstacles.

Furthermore, the two authors differ in their perspectives on the source of creativity. Lamott often draws inspiration from her own life experiences, exploring personal anecdotes and emotions to fuel her writing. She encourages writers to mine their own lives for material, offering a deeply introspective and introspective approach to creativity. Conversely, Murakami believes that inspiration can come from anywhere and encourages writers to be open to the world around them. He suggests that observing the everyday and mundane can lead to extraordinary stories, combining elements of the real and the imagined.

In conclusion, Bird by Bird and Novelist as a Profession offer contrasting perspectives on writing and creativity. While Lamott advocates for an intuitive and vulnerable approach, Murakami stresses discipline and routine. Additionally, Lamott looks inward for inspiration, while Murakami encourages writers to be receptive to the world. Though divergent, both books provide valuable insights into the writing process and offer aspiring writers different methods to adapt to their own creative journey.

Bird by Bird/logo


Both Bird by Bird by Ann Lamott and Novelist as a Profession by Haruki Murakami are renowned books that offer valuable insights into the writing process. The answer to which book is more worthy of reading ultimately depends on your personal preferences and what you are seeking to gain from a book on writing.

Bird by Bird by Ann Lamott is highly regarded for its candid and humorous approach to writing, as Lamott shares her experiences, advice, and exercises for aspiring writers. It delves into topics such as overcoming writer’s block, finding inspiration, and the importance of perseverance. Lamott’s witty and relatable writing style makes it an enjoyable read, particularly for those who appreciate a more light-hearted and personal narrative.

On the other hand, Novelist as a Profession by Haruki Murakami offers a glimpse into the mind of one of Japan’s most celebrated contemporary authors. Murakami discusses his own writing process, inspirations, and the challenges faced by a professional novelist. This book provides a deeper understanding of Murakami’s unique storytelling style and his philosophy towards writing. It is well-suited for readers who are fans of Murakami’s work and are interested in gaining insights into his creative mind.

In conclusion, both books have their merits and are widely praised in the writing community. If you are seeking practical tips and an enjoyable reading experience, Bird by Bird may be the better choice. However, if you are a fan of Haruki Murakami’s writing or interested in a deeper exploration of the creative process, Novelist as a Profession would be more suitable. Ultimately, it is recommended to read reviews and excerpts from both books to determine which one aligns better with your preferences and goals as a reader.

This Post Has One Comment

  1. avenue17

    I know, how it is necessary to act, write in personal

Leave a Reply