You are currently viewing Writing and Reading: A Comparative Analysis of ‘How to Read a Book’ and ‘Storycraft’

Writing and Reading: A Comparative Analysis of ‘How to Read a Book’ and ‘Storycraft’

——how to read a book by Mortimer J. Adler & Storycraft by Jack Hart

In the world of literature, the art of reading and storytelling has played a pivotal role in shaping our perception and understanding of the written word. It is through this lens that we embark on a comparative journey, exploring two remarkable books that delve into the intricacies of reading and storytelling: “How to Read a Book” by Mortimer J. Adler and “Storycraft” by Jack Hart.

Mortimer J. Adler’s “How to Read a Book” serves as a comprehensive guide for readers, providing them with a toolkit to unlock the depths of complex texts. Published in 1940, Adler’s masterpiece has stood the test of time, equipping generations of readers with essential skills to fully comprehend and engage with literature. On the other hand, Jack Hart’s “Storycraft” is a contemporary exploration of the art of storytelling, specifically targeted towards aspiring writers. Published in 2011, Hart’s book unravels the various elements that constitute a captivating narrative, drawing from his extensive experience as a journalist and editor.

Both books share a common ambition: to enhance the reader’s relationship with literature and empower them to engage more deeply with the written word, albeit from different angles. Adler focuses on the reader’s role, equipping them with the techniques necessary to extract meaning from texts, discriminate between different levels of understanding, and ultimately, make the most of their reading experience. Hart, on the other hand, delves into the mechanics behind storytelling, dissecting the tools and techniques that breathe life into narratives, as well as the essential ingredients that captivate and enthrall readers.

While these books approach the subject from distinct vantage points, together they form a complementary whole – offering readers a robust framework to both interpret and create literature. Starting from the initial act of reading, Adler’s book provides readers with the knowledge to navigate through various genres, develop analytical skills, and uncover the true essence of a text. Whereas Hart’s book centers around the act of storytelling, providing aspiring writers with a roadmap to crafting compelling narratives by understanding the power of structure, character development, and evocative language.

In this comparative study, we aim to explore the synergies and divergences between these two influential works, shedding light on their unique contributions to the literary discourse. By drawing from the wisdom imparted by Adler and Hart, we will examine how these books intersect to enrich our understanding of literature, imparting invaluable insights into the art of reading and storytelling.

Thus, through this comparative study, we embark on a fascinating exploration of “How to Read a Book” by Mortimer J. Adler and “Storycraft” by Jack Hart, delving into the worlds of reading and storytelling to unravel the intertwined beauty within these two literary masterpieces. Join us as we embark on a journey of discovery, embracing the transformative power of words and narratives.

Brief Summary of Two Books

how to read a book by Mortimer J. Adler

“How to Read a Book” by Mortimer J. Adler is a classic guide that aims to improve people’s reading skills and comprehension. The book breaks down the art of reading into four levels, emphasizing the importance of active reading and engagement with the material.

At its core, the book argues that reading is not simply a passive activity but a skill that needs to be cultivated. Adler offers practical advice on how to approach different types of texts, from works of literature to nonfiction books and academic papers.

The first level of reading, called elementary reading, focuses on basic comprehension. Adler advises readers to understand the structure of sentences and the meaning of individual words to grasp the author’s intended message.

The second level, called inspectional reading, involves skimming through a text to gain an overall understanding. Adler suggests techniques such as reading the introduction and conclusion, examining chapter titles and subheadings, and reading selectively to get a gist of the content.

The third level is analytical reading, which entails a more in-depth understanding of the text. Adler emphasizes the importance of asking questions, making annotations, and engaging in critical thinking. He provides guidance on how to analyze arguments and identify the main ideas in a text.

Finally, the fourth level is syntopical reading, where the reader compares multiple texts on the same subject to gain a comprehensive understanding. Adler provides strategies to synthesize different viewpoints, evaluate various arguments, and form one’s own opinion.

Throughout the book, Adler stresses the role of reading as a dialogue between the reader and the author. He encourages active participation, promotes the use of a pen to annotate and make notes, and highlights the value of a well-rounded education.

Adler’s “How to Read a Book” is considered a valuable resource for both students and lifelong learners, offering practical advice on how to approach texts with curiosity, critical thinking, and a desire for deeper understanding.

Storycraft by Jack Hart

“Storycraft: A Guide to the Art of Narrative Nonfiction” by Jack Hart is a comprehensive guide for aspiring nonfiction writers. The book provides valuable insights and practical advice on how to effectively tell true stories in a compelling and captivating manner.

Hart, a former managing editor and writing coach at The Oregonian, draws from his vast experience in journalism to guide readers through the complexities of narrative nonfiction. He emphasizes the importance of thorough reporting, meticulous research, and attention to detail in crafting a well-rounded story.

The book covers various essential elements of storytelling, including character development, scene-setting, dialogue, structure, and pacing. Hart highlights the significance of presenting characters as real, relatable individuals, and provides techniques to breathe life into them through vivid descriptions and meaningful interactions.

Additionally, “Storycraft” delves into the art of scene-setting, teaching readers how to create a vivid atmosphere that immerses readers in the narrative. Hart also explores the importance of incorporating dialogue to make the story more engaging and authentic.

Furthermore, the book focuses on the structural aspects of narrative nonfiction, guiding writers on how to organize their stories in a coherent and engaging manner. Hart emphasizes the significance of outlining, storyboarding, and revising, providing a step-by-step process for crafting a compelling narrative.

Throughout the book, Hart includes numerous examples from renowned nonfiction writers, showcasing their techniques and approaches. He also provides exercises and writing prompts to help readers practice and master the skills discussed.

In summary, “Storycraft” is a valuable resource for anyone interested in the art of narrative nonfiction. It offers a comprehensive guide to crafting engaging stories, presenting practical techniques, insightful tips, and real-world examples. With its emphasis on research, character development, scene-setting, and structure, the book equips aspiring writers with the tools necessary to become skilled storytellers in the realm of nonfiction.

Comparison between Two Books

how to read a book/logo

Similarities in Writing

To read and write similarities about the books “How to Read a Book” by Mortimer J. Adler and “Storycraft” by Jack Hart, follow these steps:

1. Start by reading both books thoroughly, making note of key concepts and ideas related to writing.

2. Analyze the structure of each book. Look for similarities in how both authors approach the topic of writing. Pay attention to the organization of chapters, sections, and any recurring themes or patterns.

3. Compare the writing styles and language used by Adler and Hart. Notice any similarities in tone, clarity, or persuasiveness. Consider their use of examples or anecdotes to illustrate their points.

4. Identify shared principles or techniques of effective writing discussed in both books. Look for common advice on topics such as storytelling, character development, narrative structure, or engaging the reader.

5. Pay attention to any similar recommendations or strategies for improving one’s writing. Look for shared tips on how to develop compelling arguments, craft compelling prose, or edit and revise effectively.

6. Consider any unique perspectives or original ideas presented by each author. Identify if there are any areas where their approaches to writing differ or offer contrasting viewpoints.

7. Look for any references or sources that are cited by both authors. This may indicate shared influences or shared understanding of the writing craft.

8. Organize your findings into sections or categories. Summarize the shared similarities in both books regarding writing principles, techniques, and advice.

9. Write a comparative analysis highlighting the similarities in the writing approaches of Adler and Hart. Begin with an introduction that briefly explains both books and your intention to explore their similarities in terms of writing guidance. Then present your findings, using clear examples and quotes from each book to support your claims.

10. Conclude by summarizing the key shared concepts and ideas you discussed. You may also add your own thoughts on the importance or effectiveness of these similarities in improving writing skills.

Remember to always properly cite any quotes or references from the books when writing your analysis.

Divergences in Writing

How to Read a Book by Mortimer J. Adler and Storycraft by Jack Hart are both valuable resources for readers and writers alike, offering unique insights and guidance. While they share a common goal of improving one’s understanding and appreciation of literature, there are clear divergences in their approach to writing.

In How to Read a Book, Mortimer J. Adler focuses on the art of reading and comprehending written works. He delves into different levels of reading, such as inspectional, analytical, and syntopical reading, providing readers with a systematic approach to extracting meaning from texts. While Adler may touch on elements of writing, his primary focus is on the reader’s engagement with the material. The book emphasizes strategies for effective reading, such as asking questions, making annotations, and organizing thoughts through note-taking. Thus, the divergence in Adler’s book lies in its limited focus on the actual act of writing.

On the other hand, Jack Hart’s Storycraft specifically targets aspiring writers, offering a comprehensive guide to the craft of storytelling. Hart explores various writing techniques, including character development, plot construction, pacing, and dialogue. He also delves into the importance of research and revision in the writing process. The book provides practical advice and examples to enhance the quality of written works, catering to writers across different genres and styles. Hart places a strong emphasis on the importance of storytelling techniques and the effective use of language, diverging significantly from Adler’s reader-focused approach.

The divergence in writing between these books becomes apparent as Adler’s work concentrates more on understanding literature, while Hart’s focus is exclusively on the craft of writing itself. Adler’s book equips readers with the skills to effectively approach and interpret various genres, whereas Hart’s work is tailored for individuals actively involved in the creation of literature.

In conclusion, How to Read a Book by Mortimer J. Adler and Storycraft by Jack Hart differ significantly in their approach to writing. Adler’s book primarily focuses on improving the reading experience and understanding of literature, whereas Hart’s work provides a comprehensive guide specifically targeting aspiring writers. While both books offer valuable insights and guidance, readers and writers may find more relevance in one or the other, based on their specific interests and objectives.

how to read a book/logo


1. “How to Read a Book” by Mortimer J. Adler:

This book offers valuable insights on reading effectively and extracting the most from books. Adler provides guidelines and strategies to help readers systematically approach different types of books, enabling them to better understand and engage with the texts. It covers topics such as different reading levels, systematic reading methods, and critical evaluation of books. This book is often recommended for individuals who want to improve their reading skills, comprehension, and critical thinking abilities.

2. “Storycraft” by Jack Hart:

This book focuses on the craft of storytelling and narrative nonfiction writing. Jack Hart, a former managing editor at The Oregonian, delves into techniques used by successful narrative journalists to captivate readers. He explores elements such as character, setting, plot, and structure, providing practical advice and examples on how to develop compelling stories. “Storycraft” is beneficial for those interested in improving their storytelling abilities, whether for journalistic purposes or other forms of writing.

Considering your personal interests and goals, you may find “How to Read a Book” by Mortimer J. Adler more valuable if you are seeking to enhance your reading skills and extract more knowledge from your reading materials. Alternatively, if you are interested in honing your storytelling abilities or narrative nonfiction writing skills, “Storycraft” by Jack Hart might be a more suitable choice.

Ultimately, both books can provide valuable insights, so you may find it helpful to read reviews, summaries, or sample chapters of each book to get a better sense of which one resonates more with your interests and goals.

Leave a Reply