Blog

In the vast realm of literature, certain stories possess the power to etch themselves into our minds, leaving an indelible impression long after we turn the final page. Breaking Night by Liz Murray and Isabella by Kirstin Downey are two such works that delve into the lives of resilient protagonists, navigating through unimaginable challenges with unwavering determination. While each book tells a distinct tale of triumph over adversity, a comparative study of these narratives invites us to explore the shared themes of resilience, family bonds, and the transformative power of education against different cultural backdrops. By analyzing the journeys of Liz and Isabella, we can gain a deeper understanding of the human spirit’s capacity to overcome obstacles and the profound impact that personal experiences can have on one’s life trajectory.

Breaking Night: A Memoir of Forgiveness, Survival, and My Journey from Homeless to Harvard is a memoir written by Liz Murray. The book provides a gripping account of Murray’s tumultuous childhood, living with drug-addicted parents in the Bronx, New York.

Murray’s parents, both drug addicts, regularly neglected her and her sister, Lisa, leaving them to fend for themselves. Growing up in extreme poverty, Murray faced countless challenges; she often went hungry and lacked a stable place to live. Despite these obstacles, Murray was determined to escape her dire circumstances and create a better life for herself.

At the age of 15, Murray’s mother passed away from AIDS-related complications, and her father became increasingly absent due to his drug addiction. Left with no options, Murray dropped out of school and began living on the streets, resorting to stealing, panhandling, and even dumpster diving for survival.

Through sheer determination, Murray managed to earn her GED and enroll in a specialized program that helped homeless youth attend college. Despite facing numerous setbacks, Murray worked tirelessly to secure scholarships and financial aid in order to attend Harvard University. Ultimately, she achieved her dream of escaping her impoverished life and transformed into a successful student.

Breaking Night serves as a testament to Murray’s resilience and determination in overcoming poverty, homelessness, and addiction. It showcases the power of education and the human spirit, illustrating that anyone can rise above their circumstances with determination and a strong will to succeed.

“Isabella: The Warrior Queen” by Kirstin Downey is a biography that chronicles the life of Queen Isabella of Castile, one of the most prominent figures in Spanish history. Downey explores Isabella’s upbringing, her rise to power, and her significant achievements as a ruler. The book showcases Isabella’s religious zeal, her determination to restore Christianity’s influence in Spain, and her central role in the Spanish Inquisition. Additionally, it delves into Isabella’s partnership with Ferdinand of Aragon, which led to the completion of the Reconquista and the unification of Spain. Downey also examines Isabella’s support for Christopher Columbus and his voyages, which expanded Spain’s imperial reach. While the book celebrates Isabella’s accomplishments, it also examines the darker aspects of her reign, including her expulsion of Jews and Muslims from Spain, and the colonization and subjugation of indigenous peoples in the New World. Overall, “Isabella” provides a multi-faceted portrait of a complex and influential ruler, shedding light on the triumphs and controversies of her reign.

Breaking Night by Liz Murray and Isabella by Kirstin Downey are both books that depict the lives of remarkable women who face significant challenges and demonstrate resilience and determination. Despite their different backgrounds and circumstances, the protagonists in both books share some similarities as great women. Here are some commonalities:

1. Overcoming adversity: Both Liz Murray and Isabella face tremendous adversity in their lives. Liz grows up in extreme poverty, with drug-addicted parents and a turbulent home life. Isabella, on the other hand, faces societal constraints being born in the 19th century, where women’s opportunities were limited. Despite these challenges, both women refuse to let their circumstances define them and strive to improve their lives.

2. Pursuit of education: Education plays a crucial role in both Liz and Isabella’s journeys. Liz’s desire for education becomes a lifeline for her, enabling her to escape her difficult home life and eventually attend Harvard University. Isabella, too, recognizes the value of education and fights for the opportunity to study medicine, even when it was not socially accepted for women in her time.

3. Unwavering determination: Liz and Isabella possess an unwavering determination to achieve their goals. Their stories are filled with instances where they face setbacks and obstacles, but they never give up. Liz’s experiences on the street and her commitment to studying amidst the chaos exemplify her resilient spirit. Isabella’s determination to challenge societal norms and pursue a career as a doctor despite gender discrimination highlights her strength.

4. Impact on others: Both Liz Murray and Isabella have a profound impact on the people around them. Liz’s resilience and success inspire others who face similar challenges, giving them hope and motivation. Isabella’s determination to become a doctor in a male-dominated profession paves the way for future generations of women in medicine, breaking down barriers and opening doors for others.

5. Advocacy and social change: Both women go beyond personal success and actively work towards social change. Liz Murray becomes an advocate for the homeless, sharing her story and championing causes related to poverty and education. Isabella dedicates her life to providing healthcare to underserved communities and actively campaigns for women’s rights.

In conclusion, Breaking Night by Liz Murray and Isabella by Kirstin Downey offer powerful narratives of two great women who overcome adversity, pursue education, exhibit determination, inspire others, and work towards social change. The similarities in their journeys highlight the extraordinary qualities that make them exceptional.

Breaking Night by Liz Murray is a memoir that recounts the author’s journey from being a homeless teenager in New York City to attending Harvard University. Isabella by Kirstin Downey, on the other hand, is a biography that tells the story of Isabella of Castile, one of the most powerful queens in history. While both books portray women who overcome incredible challenges and achieve greatness in their own right, their divergences lie in the context of their experiences and the societal limitations they faced.

In Breaking Night, Liz Murray shares her personal story of growing up in a chaotic and neglectful home as both of her parents were drug addicts. Her childhood was plagued by poverty, homelessness, and the constant struggle to survive. Despite these overwhelming obstacles, Murray eventually finds solace in education and manages to pave her way to Harvard. The book highlights the power of determination, perseverance, and the human spirit to rise above adversity, ultimately leading to Murray’s personal triumph.

On the other hand, Isabella of Castile in Isabella is a historical figure from the late 15th century. Downey explores the life of Isabella, who, contrary to Murray, was born into royalty. Isabella’s greatness stems from her political acumen, her relentless pursuit of power, and her role in uniting Spain. The book delves into her strategic marriages, her commitment to Catholicism, and her pivotal role in the exploration and establishment of colonies in the New World. Isabella’s story showcases her ability to navigate the patriarchal society of her time and ascend to a position of immense power, shaping the course of history.

While both books emphasize the power and resilience of women, they present vastly different narratives due to the contrasting societal contexts in which these women lived. Liz Murray’s story in Breaking Night focuses on her individual struggle against poverty and addiction, highlighting the triumph of an ordinary person against extraordinary odds. Isabella of Castile’s story, as portrayed in Isabella, illustrates the complication of power dynamics, politics, and societal expectations that influenced her path as a royal leader.

In conclusion, Breaking Night by Liz Murray and Isabella by Kirstin Downey depict the journeys of two extraordinary women who achieved greatness in their respective contexts. While Liz Murray’s story emphasizes personal resilience, Isabella’s story explores the complexities of power and societal limitations during the late 15th century. These divergences underline the diversity of experiences and challenges faced by great women throughout history.

“Breaking Night” is a memoir by Liz Murray that tells the inspiring story of her journey from homelessness to Harvard. It offers a powerful and moving account of resilience and determination in the face of adversity.

On the other hand, “Isabella” is a biography of Isabella of Castile written by Kirstin Downey. It provides a detailed exploration of Isabella’s life and the impact she had on shaping Spain’s history, specifically during the fifteenth century.

Consider what topics or themes resonate with you the most and choose the book that aligns with your interests. Reading reviews and summaries of both books might also help you make an informed decision.