Blog

In the realm of historical literature, countless books have been written that aim to shed light on significant events and individuals from the past. Two such works, “When Books Went to War” by Molly Guptill Manning and “Lawrence In Arabia” by Scott Anderson, delve into distinct yet equally captivating narratives. Both books offer a glimpse into remarkable moments in history, but do so from vastly different perspectives. While “When Books Went to War” illuminates the power of literature as a force for morale during World War II, “Lawrence In Arabia” explores the enigmatic life of T.E. Lawrence and his contribution to the Middle East during the same period. As we embark on this comparative study, we will examine the unique aspects of each book, evaluating their historical accuracy, narrative techniques, and overarching themes, in order to discern the strengths and weaknesses of each author’s approach. Through this exploration, we hope to gain a more comprehensive understanding of the intricate workings of literature in times of global conflict, and the enduring impact of extraordinary individuals in shaping the course of history.

“When Books Went to War” by Molly Guptill Manning is a non-fiction book that tells the captivating story of how books played a crucial role during World War II. At the height of the war, the U.S. government initiated a program called the Armed Services Editions (ASE), with the goal of providing portable and easily accessible books to the millions of soldiers serving overseas.

Manning chronicles the development of the ASE program, exploring how it transformed the literary landscape and impacted the lives of soldiers. The book reveals the immense logistical challenge of selecting appropriate books, considering soldiers’ diverse tastes and cultural backgrounds. It delves into the process of creating these pocket-sized editions and distributing them to soldiers across the world.

The ASE program not only aimed to entertain soldiers during their downtime, but also to educate and uplift them. Manning highlights the profound impact reading had on soldiers’ morale, mental well-being, and sense of connection to home. She recounts numerous anecdotes and personal accounts of soldiers who found solace and escape in the books they received.

In addition to highlighting the efforts of publishers, librarians, and soldiers who supported the program, the book explores the cultural significance of ASE. Manning discusses how books became a symbol of hope, a means of intellectual stimulation, and a form of therapy for soldiers dealing with the trauma of war.

“When Books Went to War” is a testament to the power of literature and its ability to provide comfort, escape, and enlightenment. This engaging and well-researched book sheds light on a lesser-known aspect of World War II and pays tribute to the lasting impact books had on soldiers’ lives during the war and beyond.

Lawrence in Arabia: War, Deceit, Imperial Folly, and the Making of the Modern Middle East is a historical non-fiction book by Scott Anderson. The book explores the life and actions of T.E. Lawrence, better known as Lawrence of Arabia, and how his involvement in the Arab Revolt during World War I had a profound impact on the modern Middle East.

Anderson’s book delves into Lawrence’s early life, his military career, and his transformation into a legendary figure. It highlights Lawrence’s personal struggles and his complex personality, portraying him as a charismatic, enigmatic, and sometimes contradictory character. The author also follows Lawrence’s journey through the Middle East, his interactions with various influential figures, and his interactions with different Arab groups, particularly the Hashemites led by Sharif Hussein.

The book also provides a comprehensive understanding of the political and historical context of the time, shedding light on how European powers, mainly Great Britain and France, manipulated and exploited the Arab world to further their own goals. Anderson explores the role of spies and intelligence agents, most notably German-American Curt Prufer and British intelligence officer William Yale, in shaping the events of the era.

Furthermore, Lawrence in Arabia examines the complex relationship between Lawrence and his superiors, especially British military leaders. It also delves into Lawrence’s role in the Arab Revolt, a guerilla-style conflict against the Ottoman Empire. The book depicts the challenges Lawrence faced in uniting Arab tribes, the cultural and tribal dynamics he navigated, and the military tactics he employed to disrupt Turkish communication and supply lines.

Anderson establishes that Lawrence’s experiences during the Arab Revolt significantly shaped his views on colonialism, imperialism, and the rights of native populations. Lawrence’s ambition to forge an independent Arab nation from the ruins of the Ottoman Empire ultimately clashed with the secret Sykes-Picot Agreement between Britain and France, which divided up the Arab lands for European control.

In summary, Lawrence in Arabia offers a detailed and engaging account of T.E. Lawrence’s role in the Arab Revolt, while also highlighting the broader political intrigue and imperial ambitions that affected the Middle East during and after World War I. It portrays Lawrence as a complex and pivotal figure who played an essential role in shaping the modern Middle East.

In both When Books Went to War by Molly Guptill Manning and Lawrence in Arabia by Scott Anderson, there are several similarities in their exploration of the history of wars.

1. World War I and its impact: Both books examine the period of World War I and its profound effects on society, culture, and individuals. They shed light on the devastation caused by the war and the transformative power it had on societies around the world.

2. Focus on individuals and their experiences: Both authors delve into the personal stories of specific individuals affected by war. When Books Went to War provides insights into how soldiers and civilians coped with the horrors of war through reading. Lawrence in Arabia focuses on the experiences of T.E. Lawrence and his role in the Arab Revolt during World War I.

3. Exploration of war propaganda: Both books touch upon the role of propaganda during wartime. When Books Went to War looks at how books were utilized as a tool for propaganda and morale-boosting among soldiers. Lawrence in Arabia delves into the propaganda efforts by various sides involved in the Arab Revolt and their attempts to shape public opinion.

4. Examination of the power of literature and storytelling: Both books highlight the role of literature and storytelling as a means of understanding, coping with, and documenting war. When Books Went to War emphasizes the importance of books in providing solace and escapism for soldiers during times of war. Lawrence in Arabia explores how Lawrence used storytelling and narrative to shape his own image and the perception of the Arab Revolt.

5. Social and cultural implications of war: Both authors delve into the wider societal and cultural impacts that wars have on a global scale. When Books Went to War examines how wars have the power to shape society and influence public opinion. Lawrence in Arabia explores the complexities of war in the Middle East and the broader geopolitical implications it had on the region.

While these books differ in their specific contexts and subject matter, they share common themes in their exploration of the history of wars, emphasizing the individual experiences, the power of propaganda, and the impact of literature and storytelling on society.

When comparing “When Books Went to War” by Molly Guptill Manning and “Lawrence In Arabia” by Scott Anderson, it becomes evident that the divergence lies in their portrayal of the history of wars.

In “When Books Went to War,” Manning explores the impact of World War II on American soldiers and the role books played in their lives during those turbulent times. The focus of the book is on the intellectual and emotional aspects of the war, shedding light on how soldiers found solace and escape in reading. Manning also delves into the efforts of the Armed Services Editions (ASE), a program that delivered thousands of pocket-sized books to soldiers, aiming to provide them with a connection to literature and culture despite the chaos of war. By emphasizing the importance of books for soldiers’ morale and mental well-being, Manning highlights a lesser-known aspect of the war’s history.

On the other hand, “Lawrence In Arabia” by Scott Anderson presents a comprehensive examination of the Middle East during World War I. It delves into the intricate geopolitical landscape of the region, focusing particularly on the exploits of T.E. Lawrence, better known as Lawrence of Arabia. This book aims to provide a robust historical account of Lawrence’s involvement and influence in the Arab Revolt against the Ottoman Empire, showcasing the complexity of the war’s impact on the Middle East. Anderson’s work provides a detailed analysis of the political motivations, cultural dynamics, and military strategies at play, ultimately offering readers a broader understanding of the war’s history.

Summarizing the divergence, “When Books Went to War” concentrates on the impact of World War II on American soldiers and the role books played in their lives. In contrast, “Lawrence In Arabia” delves into the history of World War I in the Middle East, focusing on T.E. Lawrence’s involvement and the broader geopolitical landscape of the region. While both books touch on different wars, their perspectives and focal points diverge, providing readers with distinct understandings of the historical events.

As an AI language model, I don’t have personal opinions or preferences. However, I can provide you with information about both books to help you decide which one may be more interesting for you.

1. “When Books Went to War” by Molly Guptill Manning: This non-fiction book tells the remarkable story of how American publishers, librarians, and the U.S. government worked together to provide books for American soldiers during World War II. It highlights the importance of books and reading in boosting morale and providing escapism during times of war.

2. “Lawrence In Arabia” by Scott Anderson: This historical biography focuses on the exploits and influence of T.E. Lawrence (also known as Lawrence of Arabia) during World War I. The book presents a portrayal of Lawrence’s life and his role in the Arab revolt against the Ottoman Empire, providing insight into the complex geopolitical landscape of the Middle East during that period.

Both books offer unique perspectives on different wartime periods and have received positive reviews. If you are more interested in the impact of books during World War II and the efforts to bring literature to soldiers, “When Books Went to War” may be the better choice. On the other hand, if you are intrigued by historical events, particularly the role of Lawrence in World War I, “Lawrence In Arabia” might be more appealing.

Consider your personal interests, preferences, and the specific historical period or topic that engages you the most to make an informed decision on which book to read.