Blog

Literature has long served as a reflection of the human experience, offering unique insights into the myriad complexities of life. In our quest to navigate life’s challenges, we often turn to written works for solace, understanding, and guidance. Two such noteworthy books are “How to Live” by Sarah Bakewell and “The Diary of a Young Girl” by Anne Frank. While seemingly distinct in their nature, both works delve into the depths of human existence, exploring resilience, self-reflection, and the enduring spirit needed to confront adversity.

Sarah Bakewell’s “How to Live” is a contemporary work that not only unravels the life philosophies of the influential French Renaissance thinker Michel de Montaigne but also examines their relevance in navigating the complexities of our modern world. Bakewell meticulously combines biographical elements with philosophical musings, amplifying Montaigne’s unique perspective on existential concerns such as love, death, truth, and friendship.

In stark contrast, “The Diary of a Young Girl” by Anne Frank offers readers an intimate, unfiltered glimpse into the life of a Jewish teenager hiding from the horrors of the Holocaust during World War II. Through a raw and introspective diary, Anne Frank details her daily struggles, fears, and aspirations, capturing the fragile existence of those living in constant fear of persecution. Despite the countless challenges surrounding her, Anne’s unwavering optimism and unwritten dream of becoming a writer showcase her remarkable spirit and determination.

While Bakewell’s exploration focuses on an intellectual figure from a different era, Anne’s diary provides a deeply personal account, highlighting the emotional hardships endured by not only herself but millions who suffered under similar circumstances. Despite these differences, both books offer striking insights into individuals’ capacity to find meaning, solace, and the will to survive amidst overwhelming adversity.

In this comparative study, we aim to delve into the philosophical, emotional, and literary elements present in Bakewell’s “How to Live” and Frank’s “The Diary of a Young Girl.” By juxtaposing their unique approaches to grappling with life’s challenges, we will explore the universal themes of resilience, existentialism, human connection, and the quest for hope in the face of unimaginable suffering.

Through a comprehensive analysis of both works, we will uncover the shared and contrasting perspectives on the human condition, humanizing philosophy, and the significance of self-reflection. By examining the societal, historical, and cultural contexts surrounding these writings, we hope to gain a deeper understanding of their lasting impact and relevance in today’s society.

As we embark on this comparative journey through the pages of Bakewell’s “How to Live” and Frank’s “The Diary of a Young Girl,” this study ultimately seeks to shed light on the enduring messages of hope, resilience, and the indomitable nature of the human spirit, regardless of the time or environment we find ourselves in.

How to Live: Or A Life of Montaigne in One Question and Twenty Attempts at an Answer” by Sarah Bakewell explores the life and philosophical ideas of Michel de Montaigne, a 16th-century French philosopher. Through twenty different chapters, Bakewell delves into Montaigne’s unique approach to living as depicted in his renowned work, “Essays”. The book is not a traditional biography but instead seeks to answer the question of how to live a meaningful life by examining the wisdom and experiences of Montaigne. Drawing from extensive research and Montaigne’s own writings, Bakewell reveals his ideas on love, friendship, education, self-knowledge, and other fundamental aspects of human existence. As she navigates through Montaigne’s ideas, Bakewell also recounts the historical context in which he lived, shedding light on the numerous challenges and opportunities he faced. “How to Live” serves as an engaging exploration of Montaigne’s life and philosophy, offering readers valuable insights into the concept of living well.

The Diary of a Young Girl” is a remarkable autobiography written by Anne Frank, a Jewish teenager hiding with her family during World War II. Anne receives a diary for her 13th birthday and begins recording her daily life inside the secret annex in Amsterdam, where her family is hiding from Nazi persecution. In her diary, Anne vividly describes the challenges, fears, and frustrations of living in confinement, along with her introspective thoughts and dreams.

Anne captures the complex relationships and dynamics among the residents of the annex, including her parents, sister Margot, the Van Daans, and a dentist named Mr. Dussel. She expresses her strong bond with her father, her admiration for her older sister, Margot, and her complicated friendship with Peter, the Van Daans’ teenage son.

As Anne grows older and desires a deeper purpose beyond their cramped confinement, her diary becomes an outlet for her ambitions and frustrations. She dreams of becoming a writer and shares her reflections on love, faith, and the human condition. This book serves as a poignant reminder of the joys, fears, hopes, and dreams of a young girl whose life was tragically cut short.

Tragically, the diary ends abruptly when the annex is discovered in August 1944 and the occupants are arrested. Anne’s remarkable diary survived and was published by her father after the war, becoming a powerful testament to the resilience, courage, and humanity of Anne Frank and all those affected by the horrors of the Holocaust.

Both “How to Live” by Sarah Bakewell and “The Diary of a Young Girl” by Anne Frank are memoirs that offer readers a glimpse into the lives and experiences of their respective authors. Despite being written in different contexts and on different subjects, these memoirs share some similarities:

1. Personal Reflectiveness: Both Bakewell and Frank engage in introspection and self-reflection throughout their memoirs. They delve into their thoughts, emotions, and experiences, providing readers with a deeper understanding of their inner worlds.

2. Conveying Human Essence: Both memoirs strive to capture the essence of being human. Bakewell explores various philosophical concepts through the lens of Renaissance thinker Michel de Montaigne’s life, while Frank’s diary documents her struggles, dreams, and aspirations during one of humanity’s darkest periods – the Holocaust.

3. Themes of Identity and Self-Discovery: Both memoirs tackle the theme of identity and the process of self-discovery. Bakewell explores Montaigne’s quest for self-understanding and his constant evolution as an individual. Similarly, Frank’s diary highlights her own journey of self-identity as she grows up, facing the challenges of adolescence in the confined space of the Secret Annex.

4. Documenting Historical Context: Although “How to Live” primarily focuses on Montaigne’s life and philosophy, Bakewell skillfully weaves historical context into the narrative, enabling readers to better understand the societal conditions that influenced Montaigne’s thinking. In a similar vein, Frank’s diary provides invaluable historical insights into the Holocaust, documenting the experiences of a Jewish family in hiding during World War II.

5. Authenticity and Raw Emotion: Both authors provide raw and genuine accounts of their lives, ensuring their memoirs feel authentic. Bakewell draws from Montaigne’s own writings, highlighting his vulnerability and humanity. Frank’s diary entries, written while she was in hiding, reveal her immediate thoughts and emotions, allowing readers to connect with her firsthand experience.

6. Universal Relevance: Despite being written in different eras, both memoirs address universal themes and emotions that transcend time and context. They allow readers to reflect on their own lives, experiences, and personal growth, making the memoirs relatable and thought-provoking.

In summary, “How to Live” by Sarah Bakewell and “The Diary of a Young Girl” by Anne Frank share several similarities as memoirs. They both offer personal reflections, convey the essence of being human, explore identity and self-discovery, document historical context, exhibit authenticity and raw emotion, and hold universal relevance for readers.

How to Live by Sarah Bakewell and The Diary of a Young Girl by Anne Frank are both memoirs that capture the personal experiences and reflections of their respective authors. However, there are significant divergences in terms of the context, purpose, and narrative style between these two books.

One apparent difference lies in the nature of the authors’ lives and the circumstances under which their memoirs were written. The Diary of a Young Girl chronicles the life of Anne Frank, a Jewish girl hiding from the Nazis during World War II. Anne’s diary serves as a personal outlet for her thoughts, feelings, and hopes while she remains confined in the clandestine annex. On the other hand, How to Live focuses on the life and ideas of Michel de Montaigne, a sixteenth-century philosopher and essayist. Bakewell’s book combines biography with philosophical exploration, seeking to understand Montaigne’s approach to living through the lens of his essays.

In terms of purpose, The Diary of a Young Girl mainly serves as a historical record, providing readers with a firsthand account of the Holocaust from a young victim’s perspective. Anne Frank’s diary serves as a testimony to the atrocities of that time, offering insights into the struggles, fears, and hopes of those living in hiding. Conversely, How to Live aims to introduce readers to Montaigne’s philosophy and wisdom. Bakewell analyzes Montaigne’s essays and presents his ideas on morality, self-reflection, and human nature. While Anne’s diary is deeply personal, Montaigne’s essays in How to Live are more analytical and philosophical in nature.

Another notable divergence pertains to the narrative style of these memoirs. The Diary of a Young Girl is presented in the form of a diary, written in a conversational and reflective manner. Anne Frank’s writing is candid, often emotionally charged, and contains diary entries, poems, and personal musings. In contrast, How to Live is a more scholarly work, blending biography, history, and critical analysis. Bakewell’s narration is objective, exploring Montaigne’s life and ideas with a greater emphasis on analysis and interpretation.

In conclusion, The Diary of a Young Girl and How to Live present divergent approaches to memoirs. Anne Frank’s diary is a personal account of life during the Holocaust, while Sarah Bakewell’s work delves into Montaigne’s philosophy. The purpose, context, and narrative styles of these books contribute to their distinctiveness as memoirs.

Both books, “How to Live” by Sarah Bakewell and “The Diary of a Young Girl” by Anne Frank, are highly regarded and have their own unique merits. The choice ultimately depends on individual preferences and interests.

“How to Live” by Sarah Bakewell is a biography that explores the life and philosophy of Michel de Montaigne, a Renaissance philosopher. Bakewell delves into Montaigne’s ideas and presents them as a guide to living a good life. If you’re interested in philosophy, self-reflection, and exploring different perspectives on life, this book would be more suitable for you. It offers an engaging look into Montaigne’s life and philosophy, while also providing insights and reflections that can be applied to our own lives.

“The Diary of a Young Girl” by Anne Frank is a poignant and powerful memoir written by Anne Frank during World War II while she was in hiding from the Nazis. It offers a firsthand account of the experiences, thoughts, and emotions of a young girl living under extraordinary circumstances. This book is deeply introspective and provides a unique perspective on the impact of war, oppression, and the human spirit’s ability to endure. If you’re interested in history, personal narratives, and stories of resilience, this book would be a compelling choice.

Both books offer valuable insights and perspectives on life, albeit in different ways. Ultimately, the choice between them depends on your personal interests, whether you lean towards philosophy and self-reflection (“How to Live”) or historical memoirs and personal narratives (“The Diary of a Young Girl”).