Blog

In the realm of architectural and artistic discourse, few phenomena can rival the enduring influence and impact of Le Corbusier’s seminal work Towards a New Architecture and Will Gompertz’s contemporary examination “What Are You Looking At.” While chronologically decades apart, these two books engage with fundamental questions surrounding creativity, expression, and the very definition of art itself. As towering figures in their respective fields, Le Corbusier and Gompertz, each armed with their distinct voices and perspectives, navigate the intricate maze of human imagination, exploring the boundaries of architecture and contemporary art.

Published in 1923, “Towards a New Architecture” stands as Le Corbusier’s magnum opus, encapsulating his revolutionary vision for urban planning, architecture, and design. With disdain for the ornamental and the superfluous, Le Corbusier advocates for a strict adherence to functionality, efficiency, and simplicity in architectural expression. Through his famous Five Points of Architecture, he sets the foundation for modernist architecture, propelling a movement that would shape the built environment for generations to come.

On the other hand, “What Are You Looking At,” written by the esteemed art critic and BBC Arts Editor, Will Gompertz, delves deep into the intricate world of contemporary art. Published in 2012, Gompertz’s book takes on the daunting task of deciphering the often enigmatic and perplexing nature of art in the twenty-first century. Drawing upon a wide range of artists, movements, and mediums, he probes the significance, meaning, and purpose behind art in a rapidly evolving cultural landscape. Through vivid storytelling and insightful analysis, Gompertz unravels the complexities of contemporary art, inviting readers to question preconceived notions and embark on a journey of artistic exploration.

The intention of this comparative study is to explore the thematic and conceptual connections that lie beneath the surface of these two influential texts. Both Le Corbusier and Gompertz grapple with the notion of artistic evolution and the quest for a new aesthetic language, albeit in different domains. By examining the philosophical underpinnings, historical contexts, and elucidating the innovative ideas put forward by these authors, it is our aim to shed light on the ways in which their works converge and diverge.

From the transformation of physical spaces to the intellectual spaces carved out by contemporary art, Le Corbusier and Gompertz offer distinct perspectives on the winds of change that shape our built environment and cultural consciousness. As we embark on this comparative journey, we navigate the passages of time, traversing nearly a century of architectural and artistic evolution, all in pursuit of a deeper understanding of the transformative power of human creativity.

“Towards a New Architecture” is a groundbreaking book written by Swiss architect Le Corbusier in 1923. It is an influential manifesto that chronicles Le Corbusier’s vision for modern architecture and urban planning in the early 20th century.

The book emphasizes the need to break away from traditional architectural styles and embrace new technologies, materials, and functionalist design principles. Le Corbusier advocates for the use of reinforced concrete as a versatile building material that would enable architects to create functional and efficient structures.

Le Corbusier argues for the importance of providing ample light, air, and space in architectural design. He criticizes the cramped and unhealthy living conditions in urban areas and proposes innovative housing solutions, such as high-rise buildings and garden cities. He also advocates for the efficient organization of cities, incorporating aspects like traffic circulation and zoning.

With strong emphasis on the functionality and practicality of design, Le Corbusier rejects excessive ornamentation and decorative elements, instead focusing on clean lines, geometric shapes, and standardization. He proposes the use of the “Five Points of Architecture,” which include pilotis (columns that lift the building off the ground), a roof garden, free facades, horizontal windows to maximize light, and an open floor plan.

Overall, “Towards a New Architecture” serves as a manifesto for the modernist movement in architecture, promoting an innovative approach that prioritizes functionality, efficiency, and the improvement of living conditions. It continues to be widely studied and influential in the field of architecture.

What Are You Looking At?” by Will Gompertz is a book that explores the history, significance, and appreciation of modern art. Gompertz, a former director at the Tate Gallery in London and now the BBC’s arts editor, takes readers on a journey through the world of contemporary art, breaking down complex concepts and making them accessible to a broader audience.

The book delves into various artistic movements, such as Impressionism, Cubism, Surrealism, and Pop Art, discussing the ideas and the artists behind them. Gompertz explains how art evolves in response to societal and cultural changes, challenging traditional notions of beauty and pushing the boundaries of creativity.

Gompertz emphasizes the importance of understanding the context in which art is created and exhibited. By examining famous artworks and their historical background, he encourages readers to approach art with an open mind, engaging with it on a deeper level rather than being dismissive or intimidated.

Additionally, the book also tackles the issue of art criticism, questioning the outdated views of critics and connoisseurs. Gompertz argues for a more inclusive and democratic approach to appreciating art, promoting the idea that everyone has the ability to form their own opinions and interpretations.

With wit and humor, Gompertz shares anecdotes and personal experiences related to modern art, making the subject more relatable and enjoyable for readers. Overall, “What Are You Looking At?” invites readers to explore and engage with the world of contemporary art, encouraging a deeper understanding and appreciation for this often misunderstood form of expression.

The books “Towards a New Architecture” by Le Corbusier and “What Are You Looking At” by Will Gompertz both touch upon the subject of art history, albeit from different perspectives.

One similarity between these books is their exploration of the impact of historical context on artistic movements. In “Towards a New Architecture,” Le Corbusier discusses how the architectural styles of the past have shaped the current built environment, and offers a vision for a modern architecture that breaks away from tradition. Similarly, Gompertz in “What Are You Looking At” delves into the historical forces that have influenced art movements throughout the centuries. Both authors acknowledge that art does not exist in a vacuum, and that social, political, and cultural factors play a crucial role in the development and understanding of artistic movements.

Additionally, both books highlight the importance of innovation and pushing boundaries in art. Le Corbusier advocates for a new approach to architectural design, one that embraces technology, functionality, and simplicity. Similarly, Gompertz explores the concept of artistic innovation and how artists throughout history have broken conventional norms to redefine art. Both authors emphasize the transformative power of bold ideas and unconventional thinking in driving artistic progress.

Furthermore, these books acknowledge the role of the individual artist in shaping artistic movements. Le Corbusier, as an architect, presents his personal vision and ideas for a new architecture, rooted in his own experiences and beliefs. Gompertz, on the other hand, focuses on the stories and struggles of individual artists who have left an indelible mark on art history. Both authors recognize the agency and individuality of artists, and how their unique perspectives contribute to the larger framework of art history.

Overall, “Towards a New Architecture” by Le Corbusier and “What Are You Looking At” by Will Gompertz share similarities in their exploration of the impact of historical context, the importance of innovation, and the role of individual artists in shaping art history. These books serve as valuable resources for understanding the development and significance of art throughout time.

Towards a New Architecture by Le Corbusier and What Are You Looking At by Will Gompertz approach the topic of art history from different perspectives and with distinct focuses, leading to a number of divergences in their content and arguments.

1. Scope and Objective:

– Towards a New Architecture: Le Corbusier’s book primarily explores the principles and philosophy behind modern architecture, advocating for a complete overhaul of traditional architectural practices. While it touches on the role of art and aesthetics in architecture, the book primarily focuses on the technical and functional aspects of designing buildings.

– What Are You Looking At: Will Gompertz’s book offers a broader overview of the history of Western art, encompassing various art movements and their societal contexts. Gompertz aims to demystify art and challenge traditional notions of what qualifies as “good art,” making it more accessible and relatable to a wider audience.

2. Structure and Format:

– Towards a New Architecture: Le Corbusier’s book is organized into a series of short essays, lectures, and manifestos, emphasizing his ideas and theories on architecture. It is more fragmented and lacks a linear narrative.

– What Are You Looking At: Gompertz’s book takes a more narrative approach, presenting art history as a coherent story that progresses chronologically. It incorporates anecdotes, biographies, and historical context to engage readers in a narrative flow.

3. Artistic Focus:

– Towards a New Architecture: Le Corbusier’s primary focus is on architecture as a functional and utilitarian endeavor. He champions the use of innovative materials, standardized design principles, and mass production techniques for the creation of efficient and affordable buildings. The book’s focus on the built environment doesn’t extensively explore other art disciplines or aesthetic theories.

– What Are You Looking At: Gompertz views art broadly, incorporating various media such as painting, sculpture, performance art, and conceptual art. He explores themes such as representation, imagination, and the cultural and social impact of art. Gompertz’s book takes a wider lens on the art world, encompassing both contemporary and historical movements.

4. Author’s Perspective:

– Towards a New Architecture: Le Corbusier writes from the perspective of an architect and urban planner, advocating for drastic changes in society. He embraces a modernist vision that seeks to improve living conditions through rationalized architecture.

– What Are You Looking At: Will Gompertz, a journalist and former director of the Tate Gallery, writes from a more critical perspective. He analyzes and questions traditional art theories, delving into the personal lives and motivations of artists. Gompertz encourages readers to develop their own interpretations and understanding of art.

In conclusion, while both books touch on the subject of art history, they diverge in terms of their scope, structure, artistic focus, and the perspectives of their authors. Towards a New Architecture mostly focuses on architectural theory, while What Are You Looking At offers a broader exploration of Western art history, challenging traditional notions of art and its meaning.

Both Towards a New Architecture by Le Corbusier and What Are You Looking At by Will Gompertz are highly regarded books in their respective fields. However, the worthiness of reading each book depends on individual interests and the goals of the reader.

If you have a keen interest in architecture and design, and are looking to explore the ideas and principles of modern architecture, Towards a New Architecture by Le Corbusier would be the more worthy book for you to read. Le Corbusier was one of the most influential architects of the 20th century, and this book is considered a seminal work in the field. It presents his vision for the future of architecture and urban planning, highlighting the importance of functionality, simplicity, and the use of modern materials.

On the other hand, if you are more interested in the world of art and art history, and want a broader understanding of the contemporary art scene, What Are You Looking At by Will Gompertz would be the more worthy book for you. Gompertz, a former director of the Tate Gallery in London, provides an insightful and accessible exploration of modern and contemporary art. He delves into the stories behind famous artworks and artists, explains different art movements, and offers a fresh perspective on how art shapes and reflects our society.

Ultimately, the choice between the two books depends on your personal interests and what you hope to gain from reading.