You are currently viewing Submerged in Biology: A Comparative Study of Deep and Beneath the Surface

Submerged in Biology: A Comparative Study of Deep and Beneath the Surface

In the vast realm of the world’s oceans lie mysteries, wonders, and untold stories waiting to be discovered. Exploring the depths of these vast underwater worlds, authors James Nestor and John Hargrove have delved into the enigmatic world beneath the surface, each offering a unique perspective through their captivating works: “Deep” and “Beneath the Surface.”

In Deep, James Nestor embarks on a mesmerizing journey into the least explored and widely misunderstood realm on our planet – the deep ocean. With an insatiable curiosity and an unyielding determination, Nestor recounts his experiences and encounters with incredible marine creatures, breathing techniques, and the inspiring narratives of daring deep-sea explorers. His work not only unveils the hidden truths of these depths but also explores the inherent connection between humanity and the ocean, inviting readers to redefine their understanding of this alien yet enchanting world.

On the other hand, John Hargrove’s “Beneath the Surface” is an emotional and thought-provoking memoir that delves into the powerful bond between humans and orcas. Drawing from his extensive twenty-year experience as a former killer whale trainer at SeaWorld, Hargrove takes us on a rollercoaster ride of heartwarming connections, tragic separations, and the dark underbelly of the theme park industry. Hargrove’s tale is not only an exploration of the majestic orcas’ behavior, intelligence, and emotional complexity, but also an exposé of the conflicting ethics surrounding their captivity, leaving readers with profound questions about our responsibility towards these magnificent creatures.

While Nestor’s “Deep” immerses us into the depths of the ocean’s realms, pulling us further away from the familiar shores, Hargrove’s “Beneath the Surface” focuses on the more visible, yet intricate, relationship between humans and marine life within human-controlled environments. These two works, poignantly written and meticulously researched, cast light on distinct aspects of the marine world, captivating readers with their remarkable blend of scientific knowledge, personal anecdotes, and diverse perspectives.

As we embark on this comparative study of Nestor’s “Deep” and Hargrove’s “Beneath the Surface,” we will unravel the similarities and differences within their narrative styles, thematic explorations, and the profound impacts these works have on our understanding of the depths below. Through their poetic prose and raw emotional accounts, Nestor and Hargrove invite us to see past the surface of the ocean, unearthing the hidden wonders and unveiling truths that will leave us enlightened and, hopefully, more compassionate towards the oceans and its inhabitants.

Brief Summary of Two Books

Deep by James Nestor

Deep is a non-fiction book written by James Nestor that explores the world of freediving and the untapped mysteries beneath the ocean’s surface. Nestor takes readers on a captivating journey, immersing them in the deep, dark world of breath-holding divers and their extraordinary abilities.

The book begins by introducing the author’s personal curiosity about the power of the breath and the transformative experiences he had while experimenting with various breathing techniques. Intrigued by the incredible freedivers he encounters, Nestor delves deeper into the realms of science, history, and mysticism to understand the secrets of these extraordinary individuals.

Nestor explores the physiological and psychological aspects of freediving, shedding light on the astonishing feats accomplished by divers who can hold their breath for several minutes and plunge hundreds of feet beneath the surface. He uncovers how the human body can adapt to extreme conditions and how training and mental preparation play crucial roles.

Delving into the history of freediving, Nestor examines the culture and traditions surrounding ancient civilizations such as the Greeks, who participated in breath-holding contests and believed in the transformative power of the deep. He reveals how these ancient practices laid the foundation for modern-day freediving.

The narrative takes readers on captivating expeditions to destinations like Greece, where Nestor spends time with world-class freedivers and learns about their techniques and training regimens. He also investigates cutting-edge scientific research conducted by biologists, chemists, and physicists to unravel the body’s physiological responses to breath-holding and deep-sea pressures.

Furthermore, Deep also explores the devastating impact humans have on the ocean ecosystem and the urgent need for its conservation. The author highlights the importance of the ocean’s health and the role it plays in our own well-being.

Overall, Deep is a compelling exploration of the human body’s incredible potential, the mysteries of the deep sea, and the power of breath. Nestor’s vivid storytelling and thorough research provide readers with an immersive and enlightening journey into the art and science of freediving.

Beneath the Surface by John Hargrove

Beneath the Surface” is a memoir written by John Hargrove, a former SeaWorld trainer. In this book, Hargrove shares his personal journey and experiences working in the marine entertainment industry, specifically focusing on his time at SeaWorld.

The book provides an inside look into the reality of the marine park industry, shedding light on the dark side of captivity for marine animals, particularly orcas. Hargrove recounts his initial fascination with these intelligent creatures and his passion for working with them. However, as he continues his career at SeaWorld, he becomes increasingly aware of the mistreatment and unethical practices towards these highly intelligent and social animals.

Hargrove exposes the reality of orca captivity, detailing the physical and psychological toll it takes on both the animals and the trainers. He discusses the tragic incidents involving orcas, such as the deaths of trainers and aggressive behavior displayed by the stressed and confined animals.

Throughout the book, Hargrove also discovers the power of activism and becomes an outspoken critic of SeaWorld’s practices. He joins forces with other former trainers and animal welfare organizations to raise awareness about the detrimental effects of captivity and advocate for the release and rehabilitation of captive orcas.

“Beneath the Surface” is a heartfelt and eye-opening account of Hargrove’s personal journey from being captivated by orcas to becoming an advocate for their freedom. It serves as a powerful critique of the marine park industry, inviting readers to question the morality of keeping these majestic creatures in captivity for entertainment purposes.

Comparison between Two Books

Similarities in biology

“Deep” by James Nestor and “Beneath the Surface” by John Hargrove both explore the world of marine biology and share several similarities in their approach to the subject. Here are some key similarities in terms of biology:

1. Dive into Marine Ecosystems: Both books provide a deep dive into the fascinating world of marine ecosystems. They explore the various species, their behaviors, and the intricate relationships that exist within these ecosystems. Through engaging narratives and scientific research, both authors shed light on the complexity and interconnectedness of marine life.

2. Focus on Cetaceans: Both Nestor and Hargrove pay special attention to cetaceans, which include whales, dolphins, and other marine mammals. They discuss the biological uniqueness of these animals, their social structures, communication techniques, and the challenges they face in their natural habitats.

3. Examination of Marine Physiology: In their books, both authors discuss the physiological adaptations that marine creatures have developed to survive in their environments. This includes details about how marine mammals have evolved to hold their breath for extended periods, cope with extreme depths and pressures, and navigate aquatic environments with remarkable precision.

4. Conservation and Environmental Issues: Both Nestor and Hargrove highlight the conservation issues surrounding marine biology. They shed light on the impact of human activities such as pollution, habitat destruction, and captivity on marine ecosystems and their inhabitants. These authors emphasize the need for increased awareness and action to preserve and protect these fragile environments.

5. Insights from Scientific Research: Nestor and Hargrove integrate scientific research findings and personal experiences into their narratives. They share anecdotes, interviews with experts, and their own observations to provide a comprehensive understanding of the biology and behavior of marine creatures.

Overall, both “Deep” and “Beneath the Surface” delve into the fascinating world of marine biology, focusing on the intricacies of marine ecosystems, the unique physiology of marine creatures, and the importance of conservation.

Divergences in biology

Deep by James Nestor and Beneath the Surface by John Hargrove are both non-fiction books that explore different aspects of the natural world, but their specific focuses and approaches to biology diverge significantly.

Deep by James Nestor delves into the science, adventure, and mysteries of free diving. Nestor explores the physiological and mental adaptations that allow humans to dive to extreme depths on a single breath and investigates the potential health benefits associated with deep diving. The book offers a biological perspective on the human body’s ability to adapt to extreme conditions while underwater, focusing on subjects such as lung capacity, oxygen utilization, and the mammalian dive reflex. Nestor’s research encompasses a wide range of biological insights, providing readers with a deeper understanding of our biological connection to the water.

On the other hand, Beneath the Surface by John Hargrove revolves around the captivity of orcas in marine theme parks. Hargrove, a former orca trainer, shares his experiences with orcas in captivity and sheds light on the issues of animal welfare, cognitive abilities, and behavioral patterns. While there are biology-related aspects discussed in the book, the primary focus is on the psychological and social impacts of captivity on these highly intelligent marine mammals. Hargrove explores topics such as the complex social structures of orcas, their ability to communicate and use echolocation, and how captivity affects their mental and physical well-being. The book raises important ethical questions surrounding the treatment of these animals and its broader implications for marine biology.

Therefore, the divergence between these books lies in their emphasis. Deep primarily examines the physiological adaptations and potentials of humans in water, while providing insights into various biological aspects related to diving. On the other hand, Beneath the Surface concentrates more on the psychological and social aspects of orcas, making the case against their captivity and highlighting the importance of understanding their biology to ensure their well-being.

In summary, the biology covered in Deep by James Nestor centers on the feats and adaptations exhibited by humans during deep diving, whereas Beneath the Surface by John Hargrove focuses on the biology and cognitive abilities of orcas in captivity, shedding light on their social structures and welfare. Both books provide valuable biological perspectives, but in different contexts and with divergent emphases.


“Deep” by James Nestor explores the world of freediving, examining the human body’s potential to adapt and survive in the depths of the ocean. Nestor combines scientific research and personal experiences to unravel the mysteries of the deep, shedding light on the physical and psychological transformations that occur during freediving.

On the other hand, “Beneath the Surface” by John Hargrove is a memoir that delves into his experiences as a former orca trainer at SeaWorld. Hargrove discusses his initial fascination with marine animals, his growing concerns about the treatment of orcas in captivity, and his decision to become an advocate for their welfare.

Ultimately, the choice between these two books depends on your personal interests and preferences. If you find the ocean and diving intriguing, “Deep” might be the more fitting option. Conversely, if you are passionate about animal welfare and interested in learning about the inner workings of the marine entertainment industry, “Beneath the Surface” could be the better choice.

Consider reading reviews or summaries of both books, or sampling a few pages to get a sense of each author’s writing style and themes. This can help you determine which book resonates more with your interests and reading preferences.

Leave a Reply