Blog

In the realm of personal and professional growth, feedback is often hailed as an invaluable catalyst for improvement. It encapsulates the power to enlighten, motivate, and transform individuals and teams alike. But what makes feedback such a complex and delicate matter? What underlying forces shape the way we give, receive, and interpret feedback? In an era where the art of feedback is more relevant than ever, two enthralling books enter the stage, each offering distinct perspectives on this multifaceted topic. “Thanks for the Feedback” by Douglas Stone and Sheila Heen, and “The Undoing Project” by Michael Lewis, delve into the intricacies of feedback and its impact on our lives, drawing upon diverse disciplines ranging from psychology to behavioral economics. While seemingly disparate in their themes and approaches, these two cognitive jigsaw pieces of literature explore the fascinating intricacies of human behavior and cognition that lie beneath the surface of feedback. Through the connections they establish between psychology, cognitive biases, and personal development, both authors strive to unravel the fundamental components that influence the way we perceive, process, and respond to feedback. By comparing Stone’s exploration of the feedback-triggered emotions and Heen’s insightful framework for receiving feedback with Lewis’s captivating narrative of cognitive biases and decision-making, this comparative study seeks to shed light on the intersectionality of these two remarkable works and the valuable lessons they offer in navigating the tumultuous seas of feedback.

“Thanks for the Feedback: The Science and Art of Receiving Feedback Well” by Douglas Stone and Sheila Heen explores the often challenging yet crucial aspect of receiving feedback effectively. Drawing on their extensive experience as negotiation consultants and feedback experts, the authors provide practical strategies to help readers appreciate and make the most of feedback in various areas of their lives.

The book emphasizes the human tendency to struggle with feedback due to our inherent desire for approval and fear of criticism. It explores three types of feedback: appreciation, coaching, and evaluation, and explains why individuals may react differently to each type. Stone and Heen emphasize that rather than focusing on the giver’s intention, the receiver should consider the value the feedback may hold, even if it comes in a less than ideal package.

The authors then introduce the three triggers that hinder feedback reception: truth, relationship, and identity. They explore how these triggers can create defensiveness, preventing individuals from engaging with feedback constructively. Stone and Heen offer strategies to manage these triggers by learning to separate the message from the messenger, recognizing personal blind spots, and embracing learning.

Furthermore, the book highlights the importance of self-awareness and growth mindset for receiving feedback. It advises readers to adopt a curious and open attitude towards feedback, viewing it as an opportunity for growth rather than a personal attack. The authors also emphasize the significance of taking ownership of one’s emotions and reactions, recognizing that feedback can be as much about the giver as it is about the receiver.

In “Thanks for the Feedback,” Stone and Heen provide valuable insights and tools for anyone seeking to improve their ability to receive feedback effectively. By exploring the dynamics of feedback, understanding personal triggers, and adopting a growth mindset, readers can develop stronger relationships, enhance their performance, and unlock their potential for growth and learning.

The Undoing Project” by Michael Lewis tells the captivating story of the groundbreaking collaboration between two Israeli psychologists, Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky. The book explores their intellectual journey, the development of their ideas, and their everlasting impact on the field of psychology, economics, and decision-making.

Lewis delves into the personal lives of Kahneman and Tversky, sharing their backgrounds, personalities, and how their unique experiences shaped their thinking. Both men were driven by curiosity and a relentless desire to understand human behavior, ultimately leading them to question the traditional assumptions of rationality in decision-making.

The core of their collaboration focused on cognitive biases, exploring the systematic errors in human judgment that occur due to specific heuristics and mental shortcuts. Through a series of ingenious experiments, Kahneman and Tversky identified various biases, such as anchoring, availability bias, and the framing effect, which have become fundamental to our understanding of human decision-making. Their work challenged the prevailing assumptions of classical economics, which assumed that individuals make rational choices based on self-interest.

Their partnership also helped shape the field of prospect theory, a groundbreaking concept that upended traditional economic thinking by demonstrating that people tend to be risk-averse when presented with gains, but risk-seeking when faced with losses. This insight revolutionized the understanding of financial markets and had far-reaching implications for economics, finance, and public policy.

“The Undoing Project” also highlights the complex dynamics and deep friendship between Kahneman and Tversky. As their collaboration flourished, they faced challenges, disagreements, and even periods of estrangement. Nevertheless, they eventually reconciled and continued their work until Tversky’s untimely death.

Through vivid storytelling and meticulous research, Michael Lewis offers an intimate portrayal of two extraordinary individuals who reshaped our understanding of human behavior and decision-making. “The Undoing Project” is a tribute to their groundbreaking work and a testament to the power of collaboration, intellectual curiosity, and the impact one’s ideas can have on the world.

Both “Thanks for the Feedback” by Douglas Stone and “The Undoing Project” by Michael Lewis touch upon the field of psychology. They explore various psychological aspects that influence human behavior and decision-making. Here are some similarities between the two books’ perspectives on psychology:

1. Cognitive Biases: Both books delve into the concept of cognitive biases. “The Undoing Project” focuses on the groundbreaking research of Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky, who explored systematic patterns of human irrationality. “Thanks for the Feedback” discusses the Confirmation Bias, which influences how people interpret feedback, often leading to selective attention to information that aligns with preexisting beliefs.

2. Human Perception: Both books highlight how human perception can be fallible. “The Undoing Project” explores how our minds often simplify complex situations using heuristics, which can result in judgment errors. “Thanks for the Feedback” looks at how individuals’ past experiences and emotions shape their interpretation of feedback, sometimes leading to inaccuracies in understanding.

3. Emotional Influences: Both books acknowledge the significant role of emotions in psychology. “The Undoing Project” delves into the impact of emotions on decision-making, showcasing how fear, pleasure, and regret can alter rational choices. “Thanks for the Feedback” emphasizes how emotions can affect how people receive feedback, sometimes leading to defensive reactions or resistance.

4. Behavioral Economics: While “The Undoing Project” specifically focuses on the field of behavioral economics, psychology and economics intertwine in both books. Both explore how human behavior and decision-making deviate from the traditional economic models that assume perfect rationality. They highlight the influence of psychological factors on economic decision-making, such as loss aversion and the framing effect.

5. Self-awareness: Both books emphasize the importance of self-awareness in psychology. “Thanks for the Feedback” encourages individuals to reflect on their own reactions and be aware of their emotional triggers when receiving feedback. “The Undoing Project” discusses how understanding one’s own biases and limitations can lead to better decision-making.

Overall, both “Thanks for the Feedback” and “The Undoing Project” provide insights into the psychology behind human behavior, decision-making, and perception. They shed light on the importance of understanding and being aware of psychological factors to navigate interpersonal dynamics and improve personal and professional growth.

While both “Thanks for the Feedback” by Douglas Stone and “The Undoing Project” by Michael Lewis touch upon the subject of psychology, they approach it from different angles, resulting in notable divergences between the two books.

1. Focus on Feedback:

“Thanks for the Feedback” primarily revolves around the topic of feedback, exploring how individuals give, receive, and utilize feedback in various contexts. It analyzes the psychology behind feedback, delving into the intricacies of why people react to feedback the way they do and suggests strategies for improving the feedback process. On the other hand, “The Undoing Project” centers around the groundbreaking work of psychologists Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky, specifically their studies on cognitive biases, decision-making, and our understanding of human behavior.

2. Application of Psychology:

While both books rely on psychological principles, “Thanks for the Feedback” provides more tangible and practical advice. It offers readers tools and techniques to navigate feedback effectively, focusing on personal development and communication skills. Contrastingly, “The Undoing Project” offers a historical account of the collaboration between Kahneman and Tversky, emphasizing their theoretical advancements in psychology. It explores their research findings and the implications they had for other fields, such as economics and medicine.

3. Scope of Psychology:

“Thanks for the Feedback” takes a broader view of psychology, incorporating insights from various psychological theories and frameworks. The book adopts a multidimensional approach, considering factors such as personality, emotions, and social dynamics. In contrast, “The Undoing Project” focuses more specifically on cognitive psychology. It delves into the workings of the human mind, emphasizing the role of biases, heuristics, and irrationality in decision-making processes.

4. Practicality vs. Academic Depth:

“Thanks for the Feedback” seeks to provide actionable advice that readers can readily apply to their daily lives. It offers practical guidance for navigating feedback conversations, resolving conflicts, and fostering growth. On the other hand, “The Undoing Project” aims to dive deep into the groundbreaking research of Kahneman and Tversky. It offers a comprehensive understanding of their experiments, drawing on their academic contributions to the field of psychology.

In summary, while both “Thanks for the Feedback” and “The Undoing Project” touch upon psychology, their divergence lies in their foci, scope, application, and their balance between practicality and academic depth. “Thanks for the Feedback” concentrates on feedback within personal and professional contexts, providing practical strategies, while “The Undoing Project” focuses on cognitive psychology and the historical significance of Kahneman and Tversky’s work.

Both “Thanks for the Feedback” by Douglas Stone and “The Undoing Project” by Michael Lewis are highly acclaimed books that offer valuable insights. However, the decision of which book is more worthy of reading ultimately depends on your personal interests and preferences.

“Thanks for the Feedback” explores the importance of feedback in our personal and professional lives. It offers practical advice on how to receive and respond to feedback effectively, improving our communication skills and relationships. If you are looking to enhance your interpersonal relationships and communication abilities, this book would be a valuable choice.

On the other hand, “The Undoing Project” delves into the fascinating story of the friendship and collaboration between two brilliant psychologists, Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky. It explores their groundbreaking research into human decision-making and the cognitive biases that often impact our choices. If you are interested in psychology, decision-making, and the human mind, this book would be a captivating and thought-provoking read.

Both books have received widespread praise and have important lessons to offer. Consider your personal interests and decide which topic resonates more with you.