Blog

In the world of writing, countless books have been penned to guide aspiring writers on their creative journey. Among these literary treasures, two standout works have captivated the hearts and minds of writers for decades: Story by Robert McKee and “Writing Down the Bones” by Natalie Goldberg. With distinct perspectives, approaches, and writing styles, these two renowned authors delve into the depths of the writing process, offering unique insights and invaluable advice. As we embark on this comparative study, we will dive into the literary worlds created by McKee and Goldberg, exploring the profound impact they have had on generations of writers and examining the contrasting methodologies they employ in crafting extraordinary narratives. Through an exploration of their techniques, intentions, and philosophies, we hope to uncover the keys to unlocking our own creative potential and discover the secrets behind crafting truly unforgettable stories. Join us as we embark on this literary journey, hand in hand with McKee and Goldberg, to unravel the mysteries of storytelling and writing, and to better understand the dynamic interplay between structure, creativity, and authenticity in the world of literature.

Story” by Robert McKee is a highly influential book on the art of storytelling. The book delves into the principles and techniques of crafting compelling narratives, primarily focusing on screenwriting but applicable to other forms of storytelling as well. McKee emphasizes the importance of structure, character development, and conflict in creating engaging stories. He breaks down the components of a compelling story, including plot, theme, and dialogue, while also exploring the role of setting, genre, and audience. Through a combination of theoretical concepts, practical advice, and detailed analysis of successful films and books, McKee teaches aspiring writers how to master the art of storytelling. By emphasizing the power of storytelling to evoke emotions and capture the human experience, “Story” offers valuable insights and guidance for those seeking to create meaningful and impactful narratives.

Writing Down the Bones” by Natalie Goldberg is a guidebook for aspiring writers seeking to unlock their creativity and improve their writing skills. The book explores Goldberg’s personal experiences as a writer and teacher, combining memoir, personal anecdotes, and practical writing exercises.

Goldberg emphasizes the importance of freewriting – the act of writing non-stop for a fixed period of time, without censorship or self-judgment. She promotes the idea of letting go of inhibitions and giving oneself permission to write freely and truthfully. The author encourages writers to write from a place of honesty and vulnerability, believing that this is where the most powerful and authentic work resides.

The book also tackles various obstacles and challenges that writers commonly face, such as self-doubt, procrastination, and writer’s block. Goldberg provides strategies and techniques to overcome these hurdles, including setting specific writing goals, establishing a regular writing practice, and engaging in writing exercises to tap into creativity and imagination.

Goldberg further explores the connection between writing and Zen Buddhism, sharing the idea of “writing as a practice” and how writing can become a means of self-discovery and spiritual growth. She emphasizes the importance of mindfulness and being fully present in the writing process, encouraging writers to observe the world around them with a curious and compassionate mindset.

Overall, “Writing Down the Bones” offers a combination of practical advice, inspiration, and encouragement for writers at any stage of their journey. Goldberg’s personal stories and insightful guidance provide a roadmap for harnessing creativity, developing a writing practice, and embracing the joy and passion of writing.

While Story by Robert McKee and Writing Down the Bones by Natalie Goldberg approach writing from different perspectives and with different focuses, there are several similarities that can be drawn between the two books.

Firstly, both McKee and Goldberg emphasize the importance of discipline and consistency in the writing process. McKee highlights the need for writers to fully commit themselves to their craft, emphasizing that writing is not a casual hobby but a serious undertaking that demands dedication and perseverance. Similarly, Goldberg emphasizes the practice of daily writing, urging writers to establish a routine and make writing a regular part of their lives. Both authors stress that writing requires discipline, and that success comes from consistently showing up to do the work.

Secondly, McKee and Goldberg both stress the importance of honing one’s observational skills. McKee argues that writers must maintain a keen awareness of the world around them, as well as a deep understanding of human behavior and emotions, in order to create believable and compelling stories. Goldberg echoes this sentiment, encouraging writers to be fully present and engaged with their surroundings, urging them to pay attention to the details and sensations of life. Both authors believe that strong writing stems from being an astute observer of the world.

Furthermore, both McKee and Goldberg acknowledge the challenges and struggles that writers face. McKee emphasizes the necessity of embracing conflicts and obstacles in storytelling, noting that characters must undergo trials and tribulations to create compelling narratives. Similarly, Goldberg acknowledges that the writing process can be arduous and frustrating, filled with self-doubt and writer’s block. Both authors stress the importance of pushing through these difficulties and persisting in the face of adversity.

Lastly, both McKee and Goldberg encourage writers to find their unique voice and writing style. McKee emphasizes the importance of authenticity and individuality in storytelling, encouraging writers to tap into their own perspectives and experiences to create narratives that resonate with readers. Similarly, Goldberg advocates for writers to let go of inhibitions and fears, urging them to write from a place of deep honesty and vulnerability. Both authors believe in the power of finding and embracing one’s unique voice as a writer.

In sum, while Story by Robert McKee and Writing Down the Bones by Natalie Goldberg approach writing from different angles, the books share similarities in their emphasis on discipline, observation, overcoming challenges, and finding one’s voice. These common themes provide valuable guidance and insight for writers seeking to improve their craft.

Story by Robert McKee and Writing Down the Bones by Natalie Goldberg are both highly regarded books that offer guidance and insights into the craft of writing. While they both share the common goal of helping writers improve their skills, there are notable divergences in their approaches and emphasis on different aspects of writing.

1. Structure vs. Freedom:

One significant divergence between the two books lies in their approach to structure. Robert McKee’s Story is heavily focused on the principles of traditional storytelling, with an emphasis on structure, plot, and character development. McKee believes in the necessity of understanding and adhering to the principles of storytelling to create compelling narratives.

On the other hand, Natalie Goldberg’s Writing Down the Bones takes a more free-flowing and spontaneous approach. Goldberg encourages writers to let go of inhibitions and follow the natural flow of their thoughts, emphasizing the importance of free writing and capturing the essence of the moment without worrying too much about structure.

2. Craft vs. Process:

Another divergence between the two books is the emphasis they place on the craft of writing versus the process of writing. In Story, McKee provides a thorough breakdown of the craft, delving into the technical elements of storytelling, such as character arcs, plot development, and dialogue construction. The focus is on developing strong technical skills to construct compelling narratives.

In contrast, Writing Down the Bones by Goldberg leans more towards the process of writing. Goldberg emphasizes the importance of discipline, dedication, and perseverance in the writing process. She encourages writers to show up regularly, cultivate a writing routine, and be open to the serendipitous nature of creativity.

3. Analysis vs. Inspiration:

Story by Robert McKee tends to be analytically oriented, often using examples and dissecting well-known films and stories to illustrate his points. McKee’s book is packed with theory, analysis, and practical advice derived from his extensive experience in screenwriting. It offers an in-depth understanding of the principles that underpin successful storytelling.

Writing Down the Bones, on the other hand, is more inspirational and experiential. Goldberg focuses on encouraging writers to tap into their inner creativity, trust their instincts, and find their unique voice. The book contains numerous personal anecdotes, writing exercises, and prompts to awaken the writer’s inner muse and cultivate a sense of exploration and discovery.

In conclusion, while both Story by Robert McKee and Writing Down the Bones by Natalie Goldberg provide valuable insights into the art of writing, they differ in their approach. McKee’s book leans towards a structured, analytical, and craft-focused perspective, while Goldberg’s book encourages a more spontaneous, process-oriented, and inspirational approach to writing. Depending on the writer’s preferences and needs, both books offer valuable perspectives that can enhance their writing skills.

Both “Story” by Robert McKee and “Writing Down the Bones” by Natalie Goldberg are highly recommended books for anyone interested in writing.

“Story” is a renowned guide to the art of storytelling. In this book, McKee provides a comprehensive breakdown of the fundamental principles of storytelling, exploring plot structure, character development, and the importance of conflict. This book is highly regarded by writers, screenwriters, and filmmakers for its insightful analysis and practical approach to storytelling. If you are interested in understanding the mechanics of storytelling and developing your writing skills, “Story” is an excellent choice.

On the other hand, “Writing Down the Bones” by Natalie Goldberg takes a more personal and introspective approach to writing. Goldberg emphasizes the importance of free-writing and the practice of writing as a means of self-expression and exploration. She encourages writers to tap into their creative potential by breaking through fears and embracing the act of writing itself. This book is more about the process of writing and the transformation it can bring to the writer.

Therefore, the choice between the two books depends on your specific interests and goals as a writer. If you are primarily interested in learning about the technical aspects of storytelling, “Story” by Robert McKee is the way to go. However, if you are looking for inspiration and guidance on how to develop a writing practice and connect with your creativity, “Writing Down the Bones” by Natalie Goldberg is a valuable resource. Ultimately, both books have their own unique insights to offer and are worthy of reading for anyone interested in the craft of writing.