Blog

Comparing two literary works is often an intriguing exercise, as it allows us to delve into the complexities and parallels that exist within human experiences and personal narratives. In this comparative study, we shall embark on an exploration of two captivating autobiographical works: “The Story of My Life” by Helen Keller and “Educated” by Tara Westover.

“The Story of My Life” is a timeless classic that chronicles Helen Keller’s remarkable journey from a world of isolation and darkness to becoming a symbol of hope and resilience. Struck by an illness at the tender age of nineteen months, Helen Keller was left both blind and deaf. However, with unwavering determination and the guidance of her beloved teacher, Annie Sullivan, she defied societal expectations and unlocked a world of knowledge and self-expression.

In a similar vein, Tara Westover’s “Educated” offers a riveting account of her unconventional upbringing in rural Idaho. Cut off from the outside world by her ultra-religious family, Tara’s access to education was limited, if not non-existent. Despite this, her thirst for knowledge propelled her to break free from the constraints of her upbringing, eventually leading her to earn a coveted place at Cambridge University.

While these two autobiographies differ vastly in their circumstances and timelines, they share distinctive themes such as the transformative power of education, the indomitable spirit of the human soul, and the pursuit of personal growth against all odds. Both Keller and Westover bravely confront barriers that threaten to confine them to the periphery of society and actively seek means to expand their intellectual horizons.

Throughout this comparative study, we aim to uncover the nuances and similarities between “The Story of My Life” and “Educated.” By delving into the authors’ experiences, struggles, and triumphs, we hope to gain a deeper understanding of how education can transcend limitations and forge paths towards individual empowerment and liberation.

Through an exploration of their distinct journeys, we will analyze the various factors that shaped their identities and examine the role of education in shaping their worldviews. Moreover, we shall delve into the underlying obstacles they encountered on their paths to self-discovery, offering insights into the societal, familial, and internal dynamics that influenced their trajectories.

Intriguing and thought-provoking, the comparative study of “The Story of My Life” and “Educated” not only invites us to understand the authors’ lives on a personal level but also encourages us to reflect upon the broader themes of education, freedom, and the human capacity for growth. Join us as we embark on this enlightening journey, unraveling the stories of these remarkable women and the lessons they teach us about the transformative power of knowledge and determination.

“The Story of My Life” is an autobiography written by Helen Keller, detailing her journey from childhood to adulthood. Helen Keller was born deaf and blind, being unable to communicate with the world around her until Anne Sullivan, her dedicated teacher, arrived. Through Anne’s patience and guidance, Helen learned to communicate using a system of touch and sign language.

The book primarily focuses on Helen’s experiences and achievements. It narrates the challenges she faced in learning how to communicate and navigate the world, as well as her determination to overcome these obstacles. Helen shares her memories of childhood, her education at Radcliffe College, and her travels around the world.

Helen also reflects on her deep love for literature and her passion for advocating for the rights of individuals with disabilities. She became an influential writer, speaker, and advocate, using her own experiences as a testament to the potential within every individual.

“The Story of My Life” is an inspiring narrative that emphasizes the power of dedication, perseverance, and the indomitable human spirit in overcoming adversity.

“Educated” is a memoir written by Tara Westover, detailing her journey from a childhood in rural Idaho, USA to eventually earning a PhD from Cambridge University. The book depicts Tara’s upbringing in a strict and abusive household, where her family was deeply religious and hostile towards mainstream education and institutions. Despite facing numerous obstacles, including physical and emotional abuse, Tara develops a thirst for knowledge and education. With the help of a few mentors and her own determination, she manages to escape her isolated and controlling environment, eventually achieving academic success. “Educated” is a compelling story of resilience, self-discovery, and the transformative power of education.

Both “The Story of My Life” by Helen Keller and “Educated” by Tara Westover feature incredible women who defy the odds and overcome immense challenges to ultimately achieve greatness. While their circumstances and journeys are distinct, there are several striking similarities between these remarkable women.

1. Determination and Resilience:

Both Helen Keller and Tara Westover exhibit an unwavering determination and resilience in the face of extraordinary obstacles. Keller, who was both deaf and blind from a young age, refused to let her disabilities define her and tirelessly worked towards her education and personal growth. Similarly, Westover, raised in a strict and abusive household in rural Idaho, displayed immense resilience as she pursued her education against all odds, eventually earning a doctorate from Cambridge University. Both women refused to let their circumstances limit their potential and instead chose to rise above them.

2. The Power of Education:

Education plays a central role in the lives of both Keller and Westover. For Keller, access to education represented a breakthrough in her communication and understanding of the world. Learning to read and write was a transformative experience that allowed her to share her story and advocate for the rights of others with disabilities. In Westover’s case, education served as her ticket to escape the oppressive environment in which she was raised. Through education, she discovered a whole new world beyond her isolated upbringing, empowering her to break free from her family’s restrictive beliefs and pursue her own dreams.

3. Supportive Mentors:

Both Keller and Westover had influential mentors who played instrumental roles in their paths to success. In Keller’s case, her teacher and lifelong companion, Anne Sullivan, was paramount in unlocking her potential. Sullivan’s patience, dedication, and tutelage enabled Keller to navigate the world despite her physical limitations. For Westover, her introduction to education was facilitated by her older brother Tyler, who encouraged her to pursue an education and guided her through the college application process. These strong mentor figures provided guidance, support, and inspiration to the two women, proving the significance of having someone who believes in one’s potential.

4. Advocacy for Others:

Keller and Westover both used their experiences and education as platforms to advocate for the rights and well-being of others. Keller tirelessly campaigned for the inclusion and equal treatment of people with disabilities, emphasizing that they too could lead meaningful lives given access to education and opportunity. Similarly, Westover confronted the oppressive practices and beliefs within her own family and community in her memoir, shedding light on the need for education and personal growth as a means of liberation. Both women leveraged their own stories to shine a spotlight on broader societal issues, inspiring others to challenge the status quo and champion change.

In summary, both Helen Keller and Tara Westover embody the qualities of determination, resilience, the transformative power of education, the presence of supportive mentors, and the inclination to advocate for others. Through their exceptional stories, these great women have left a lasting impact, not only within the context of their books but also on broader society.

The Story of My Life by Helen Keller and Educated by Tara Westover are both captivating memoirs that chronicle the lives of extraordinary women. While both books delve into the challenges and triumphs of their respective authors, they differ in various aspects, especially in terms of the circumstances surrounding their lives and the impact they have had on the world.

One prominent divergence between the two books lies in the scope of the societal barriers the authors faced. Helen Keller’s story is a testament to her indomitable spirit and determination as she navigated a world of darkness and silence due to being both blind and deaf. Despite her disabilities, Keller overcame immense odds, thanks to the support of her teacher Anne Sullivan. Her intellectual and emotional growth was truly remarkable, as she broke through the barriers imposed upon her and became a renowned author and activist. Through her extensive writings and speeches, Keller brought attention to the challenges faced by individuals with disabilities and advocated for their rights, thus making a significant contribution to promoting inclusivity and understanding.

On the other hand, Tara Westover’s Educated portrays a different kind of barrier – the oppressive and isolating environment created by her fundamentalist family in rural Idaho. Westover grew up without formal education, medical care, or exposure to the outside world due to her parents’ extremist beliefs. However, she tenaciously sought knowledge, eventually escaping her cloistered existence and gaining admission to prestigious universities. Westover’s memoir not only showcases her exceptional resistance to familial restrictions but also highlights the transformative power of education. Through her story, she sheds light on the importance of intellectual freedom, critical thinking, and the ability to question and challenge societal norms.

The impact of these remarkable women on society also diverges. Helen Keller, with her advocacy for the rights of people with disabilities, became an iconic figure in American history. Her influence extended beyond her lifetime, as her work paved the way for improved education and opportunities for individuals with disabilities. Keller’s legacy as an influential writer, speaker, and activist continues to inspire those facing adversity.

In contrast, Tara Westover’s impact has been more localized but equally consequential. Through Educated, she sheds light on the importance of access to education and the transformative power it possesses. Westover’s story has become a catalyst for discussions surrounding abusive families, the limitations of extreme fundamentalism, and the healing potential of education. Her memoir resonates with readers worldwide and acts as an inspiration for those seeking liberation from oppressive circumstances.

In conclusion, both The Story of My Life and Educated depict the lives of extraordinary women who overcame significant barriers to emerge as powerful voices in society. While Helen Keller’s story focuses on the challenges faced by individuals with disabilities and her advocacy work, Tara Westover’s memoir showcases the importance of education and its ability to liberate individuals from oppressive circumstances. Despite their diverging themes and impact, both books celebrate the resilience, perseverance, and strength of these great women.

Both “The Story of My Life” by Helen Keller and “Educated” by Tara Westover are highly acclaimed memoirs that offer powerful insights into the human spirit and the pursuit of education. Deciding which book is more worthy of reading ultimately depends on personal interests and preferences.

“The Story of My Life” is Helen Keller’s autobiography, documenting her journey from being deaf and blind since childhood to becoming a renowned author, political activist, and lecturer. Keller’s resilience and determination to overcome her disabilities, as well as her remarkable relationship with her teacher, Anne Sullivan, make for a touching and inspiring read. This classic memoir offers profound reflections on perseverance, communication, and the boundless potential of the human mind.

In contrast, “Educated” is Tara Westover’s memoir, recounting her upbringing in a strict and abusive household in rural Idaho, where she was denied access to formal education. Despite immense challenges, Westover teaches herself mathematics and eventually gains admission to Cambridge University. “Educated” is a gripping and thought-provoking exploration of self-discovery, the transformative power of education, and the complexities of family loyalty.

Considerations for choosing one over the other may include personal affinity for historical narratives, as Helen Keller’s story unfolds in the late 19th and early 20th century, while Tara Westover’s story is more contemporary. Additionally, the themes that resonate most with individual readers, such as the triumph of the human spirit or the importance of education, can further inform the decision.

Ultimately, both “The Story of My Life” and “Educated” offer profound and inspiring accounts of individuals who triumph over adversity and find their place in the world. Reading either of these books would provide valuable insights into the human experience, and it ultimately comes down to personal preference and areas of interest.